Travel and vehicles

Annual maintenance contract or pay per service: which costs less?

Annual maintenance contract or pay per service? Total your last three years of bills, then line up the package price against it, leaving out wear items.

Editorial illustration for Annual maintenance contract or pay per service: which costs less?

An annual maintenance contract costs less than pay-per-service only if the package price is below what you would have spent on the same routine services, and only if you actually use every service in it. Add up the last three years of routine service bills, strip out the wear items the package excludes, and divide by the number of services. If the package works out cheaper per service, it is worth a closer look.

How do you total what you actually spent?

Pull every workshop bill from the last three years. Sort each one into two groups: routine service work such as labour, oil, filters and checks, and wear items such as tyres, battery, brake pads and wipers. Packages normally cover the first group and exclude the second, but check the exact list in the offer. Here is a made-up history of two services a year.

YearRoutine service bills (₹)Wear-item bills (₹)
17,000 (two services)0
27,500 (two services)2,600 (brake pads)
38,100 (two services)5,500 (battery)
Total22,6008,100

How do you compare it with a package?

Say the package costs ₹21,000 for three years and includes six routine services. The package works out to ₹21,000 divided by 6, which is ₹3,500 per service. Your history shows ₹22,600 divided by 6, which is about ₹3,767 per service. The package is ₹1,600 cheaper over three years on routine work, and the ₹8,100 of wear items would have been paid either way.

What should you check before you sign?

  • Exactly which services and how many are included, and over what period.
  • What is excluded: wear items, accident repair, anything the manual lists as chargeable.
  • Whether taxes are included in the price quoted.
  • Whether the package is tied to one workshop or to a network of them.
  • Whether the contract can be transferred if you sell the vehicle, and whether any unused services can be refunded.
  • Whether you must prepay everything now.

Is the cheaper option always the better one?

Not by price alone. A package ties up money upfront, binds you to one workshop network and may lose value if you sell early or drive fewer kilometres than planned. Pay-per-service keeps you flexible and lets you choose a workshop each time. The package buys price certainty if workshop rates rise. Neither is the answer for everyone, so run your own numbers and then decide which trade you prefer.

What if your history is incomplete?

  1. Start with the bills you have and mark the gaps.
  2. Use the statement for missing years to find workshop payments.
  3. Ask the workshop for a service history print-out, which many keep.
  4. If you cannot rebuild three years, compare per service using the visits you can document and say clearly that the sample is small.

What about the next three years?

Your future services may not look like your past ones. A newer vehicle needs less, an older one more, and your usage may change. Look at the service schedule in the manual for the next three years and see which services fall in that window. If a big service is coming that was not in your history, the package may look better than the history suggests; if you plan to sell soon, it may look worse.

Where does SpendixAI help?

If workshop payments arrive through uploaded statements, you can categorise them as vehicle service and wear items separately, then run a report across three years to get the totals the table above needs. Cash payments can be added by hand.

A simple decision list

  • Routine service total divided by number of services, from your history.
  • Package price divided by number of services included.
  • Subtract, then adjust for anything excluded or prepaid.
  • Ask the dealer for the exclusions in writing before you pay.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports