Comparisons

Best apps to move from another app: compared for India

Switching trackers means moving your history. We compare how Money Manager, Wallet, Spendee, YNAB, Monarch, Goodbudget and SpendixAI handle imports and exports, and what Mint users got.

Editorial illustration for Best apps to move from another app: compared for India

Changing expense apps is rarely a one-click job. Each product stores your history its own way, and the way in is usually a file. Here is what we could verify about moving between the apps we covered, and which ones leave you needing a workaround.

SpendixAI is our own product, so judge our summary of it with that in mind; the others are described only from what their pages say.

Two directions: out of the old app, into the new one

Moving has two halves. First you must get your records out of the old app, usually as CSV or a backup. Then the new app must accept them. Many apps are decent at one half and weak at the other.

How each tool handles it

  • Money Manager (Realbyte): fill an Excel template, export it as a tab-separated file and import it through the Backup menu. Realbyte advises .sqlite backups for restores, and its help articles are about three to four years old.
  • Wallet by BudgetBakers: imports CSV, XLS, XLSX and OFX, on the web app only, and only into General accounts that are not bank-linked. No PDF in the standard import.
  • Spendee: imports xls, xlsx and CSV up to 10 MB through the web app, into cash wallets only, with no duplicate or transfer detection. Export to CSV or XLS happens in the mobile app only.
  • YNAB: file import works anywhere, with CSV preferred and OFX, QFX and QIF also accepted. It is described as a web-app feature.
  • Monarch Money: web-only CSV import, which needs account, amount and date columns. Imports cannot be undone.
  • Goodbudget: transactions can be downloaded as CSV; we found no import described.

What happened to Mint users

Intuit ended Mint in late March 2024. Users were moved to Credit Karma where eligible, with linked accounts, balances, net-worth history and about three years of transactions carried over, after which the Mint profile became inaccessible. Credit Karma has no monthly or category budgets, according to Intuit support. Mint was US-only, so it was not an Indian option to begin with.

Comparison table

ProductFile importWhere import worksNotes for India
Money Manager (Realbyte)Excel via templateMobile app Backup menuNo bank sync or SMS described
Wallet by BudgetBakersCSV, XLS, XLSX, OFXWeb app, General accounts onlyBank sync in India could not be confirmed
Spendeexls, xlsx, CSV, 10 MB limitWeb app, cash wallets onlyIndian bank providers could not be confirmed
YNABCSV, OFX, QFX, QIFDescribed as web-app featureNo direct bank link in India
Monarch MoneyCSV, web onlyWeb, cannot undoOther countries could not be confirmed
GoodbudgetNo import describedNot applicableNo India bank sync
SpendixAIStatements as PDF, CSV or ExcelYou pick the account first; review rows before savingBuilt for Indian bank and card statements

How SpendixAI handles a move

We found no import of another app's backup described for SpendixAI. It imports bank and card statements as PDF, CSV or Excel. So the practical route is to bring your history from the source: download statements from your bank for the period you care about, choose the account, upload in batches, review the rows and save. Possible duplicate imports are flagged, and an import history shows the status of each upload. If you also keep a separate record in your old app, the cleaner approach is to run both for a month and compare.

One thing to settle before you start: the base currency must be chosen before importing and cannot be changed once transactions exist. Check that against the other tools above, where currency handling varies or is unclear.

Which route is easiest?

If your old app produced a clean CSV, YNAB and Wallet are the most flexible receivers among those we read, though neither is built around Indian bank statements. If your history lives in bank statements, SpendixAI is the one made for that job. Prices were checked in November 2026 and change, so confirm each on the product's own page before committing.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports