Income and work

Best, base and low case: budgeting before the appraisal result

Appraisal result still pending? Prepare best, base and low monthly budgets from a made-up spend list so the new payslip simply tells you which applies.

Editorial illustration for Best, base and low case: budgeting before the appraisal result

Before an appraisal result arrives, prepare three monthly budgets: low (no change in pay), base (the raise you expect) and best (a better one). Keep the spending list identical in all three and let only the leftover change. Then the new payslip just confirms which version you are living in, and you do not make big decisions on guesses.

Why three budgets and not one?

A single guess hides the risk. If you budget for the hike and the pay does not rise, you may have already agreed to a bigger rent or a loan. If you budget for no hike and it comes, you may delay a good decision. Three versions force you to ask what changes, and what does not.

Build the common spend list first

Use the last three months of your own category totals as the starting point. In this made-up household the monthly list is as follows.

  • Rent ₹20,000, food ₹11,000, transport ₹4,500, utilities and phone ₹5,500
  • Loan EMI ₹7,000, insurance ₹2,500, other spending ₹5,000
  • Total: ₹55,500

Your own list will differ, but notice that it is the same in all three scenarios. Raises should not change the list until you decide, deliberately, to change it.

What does each scenario show?

ScenarioMonthly take-homeSpend listLeft overPlanned use of leftover
Low (no change)₹60,000₹55,500₹4,500All to savings
Base (modest rise)₹63,000₹55,500₹7,500All to savings goals
Best (bigger rise)₹66,000₹55,500₹10,500₹8,000 to goals, ₹2,500 spare

The differences: ₹63,000 minus ₹55,500 is ₹7,500, and ₹66,000 minus ₹55,500 is ₹10,500. Even the low case leaves ₹4,500, so no bill is at risk in any scenario.

What should I decide before the result?

  1. What you will do with each leftover amount, written in the table, so you are not deciding on result day.
  2. The latest day you will wait: if the revised pay is not on a payslip by a date, run the low case.
  3. Which commitments are on hold until the payslip: a new lease, a larger loan, a big purchase.
  4. What stays the same: insurance, EMIs and any regular family support.

How do I use the payslip when it arrives?

Compare the first clean payslip with the three columns. Match its net amount to the closest column and adopt that one. If it falls between two, use the lower. Arrears paid with the first payslip should be treated as one-offs, kept outside the monthly plan. If your statements are imported into SpendixAI, the category totals for the last three months are already there to build the spend list, and you can compare the new month against it after the payslip.

What about a hike that comes with a role change?

If the new role adds costs, such as a longer commute or a different city, add a fourth column with those extra lines before you decide. The pay rise alone may not be the full story.

How long should I wait before trusting the result?

Until the new amount is on a payslip and in your bank account. Letters and portal updates can be revised, and some raises start from a future month. Use the low case for any decision that cannot be reversed in the meantime. If a decision can be reversed or postponed, postpone it. The waiting costs little, and a mistake in the other direction can last for years.

A closing checklist

  • Take three months of category totals for the spend list.
  • Write the three scenarios with leftover amounts.
  • Pre-decide the use of each leftover.
  • Hold new commitments until the second credit.
  • Pick the matching column when the payslip lands.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports