Debt

Taking the chit early or late: arithmetic with sample numbers

Taking the chit pot in month 3 or month 18? A worked comparison of total paid against net received, using assumed discounts and dividends.

Editorial illustration for Taking the chit early or late: arithmetic with sample numbers

Taking a chit early gives you cash sooner but costs more in total; taking it late costs less and can even leave you ahead. The sums below compare month 3 with month 18 in one invented chit, using total paid and net received. The discounts and dividends are assumed, so use them as a method, not as a forecast.

What are we comparing?

A chit of 20 members, each paying ₹5,000 a month for 20 months, with a pot of ₹1,00,000. In this example every member shares each month's dividend up to and including the month they win, and none after. Dividends are the month's discount divided by 20. The assumed discounts shrink over time, so winning early costs more.

ItemTake in month 3Take in month 18
Assumed discount that month₹15,000₹3,000
Pot received (₹1,00,000 less discount)₹85,000₹97,000
Dividends shared up to that month₹2,650₹8,900
Total paid over 20 months (₹1,00,000 less dividends)₹97,350₹91,100
Received minus paid-₹12,350+₹5,900

How are the totals worked out?

In month 3 the dividends you shared are ₹1,000 + ₹900 + ₹750 = ₹2,650. Your total paid is 20 x ₹5,000 = ₹1,00,000, less ₹2,650, which is ₹97,350. You received ₹85,000. So the net is ₹85,000 - ₹97,350 = -₹12,350.

In month 18, the dividends added up to ₹8,900 under the assumed discounts. Your total paid is ₹1,00,000 - ₹8,900 = ₹91,100, and you received ₹97,000. The net is ₹97,000 - ₹91,100 = +₹5,900.

What is the early month buying me?

The difference between the two choices is ₹5,900 + ₹12,350 = ₹18,250. In return the early taker has ₹85,000 from month 3, fifteen months before the late taker. The cost of that, in this example, is ₹12,350 on ₹85,000, which is ₹12,350 / ₹85,000 = about 0.145, or roughly ₹14.50 for every ₹100 received.

The late taker, in effect, lends the group their instalments for longer, and is rewarded: ₹5,900 on ₹91,100 paid is about ₹6.50 for every ₹100 paid in. These are proportions of the invented numbers, not rates for any chit.

What should I ask myself before choosing?

  • Do I need the money now, or would I only like to have it?
  • What would I otherwise do to raise ₹85,000, and what would that cost?
  • Can I keep paying ₹5,000 every month until month 20, including after I receive the pot?
  • If I wait, is there a risk I will need it in a month when I cannot bid?

Do not guess the discount. Ask your organiser for the past months' winning bids and dividends, and build your own table from those.

How do I run the comparison for my own chit?

  1. Write down the contribution, the number of members and the term.
  2. For each month, list the winning bid, the discount and the dividend.
  3. For a candidate month, add the dividends up to and including it.
  4. Total paid = contribution x months, less those dividends.
  5. Received = pot less discount in that month.
  6. Received minus paid is the net for that month.

If you repeat the steps for two or three possible months, the table shows how the net changes. A spreadsheet makes this quick, and SpendixAI can hold the monthly contribution transfers so that your real payments sit alongside the plan.

When is a professional worth asking?

If the chit is large, if you are unsure how the organiser calculates dividends, or if you are considering taking a loan to join, ask a CA or an experienced advisor. This article explains arithmetic with assumed numbers; it does not tell you what to choose.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports