Business

Borrowing for stock: supplier credit, bank loan or a friend?

Borrowing for shop stock: compare supplier credit, a bank loan and a friend on one made-up Rs 50,000 purchase, including cost, speed and goodwill risk.

Editorial illustration for Borrowing for stock: supplier credit, bank loan or a friend?

When you need to borrow money for shop stock, the three usual sources are supplier credit, a bank loan and a friend. Each has a different cost, speed and risk, and the cheapest in rupees is not always the cheapest overall. The best way to decide is to put the same stock purchase through all three and see what each one costs and what happens if you pay late.

What is the made-up stock purchase?

Say you need ₹50,000 of stock for the festival season. The numbers below are invented only so that the comparison is concrete. Ask each source for its real terms in writing.

MeasureSupplier creditBank loanA friend
Cost in rupees₹1,000 extra for 30 days₹54,000 repaid over six months plus ₹1,000 feeNo interest agreed
Total extra paid₹1,000₹5,000₹0
SpeedSame day, if the supplier agreesDays or weeks, with papersSame day
FlexibilityFixed 30-day termFixed monthly instalmentsWhatever you agree
If repayment slipsCredit may stop next timeLate charges in the loan papers and a strained recordStrained relationship

The bank loan cost is 54,000 minus 50,000, which is 4,000, plus the 1,000 fee, making ₹5,000 over six months, or about ₹833 a month. The supplier's ₹1,000 for one month is the same as paying 2 per cent for 30 days, and per month of borrowing that is more than the bank's ₹833, though a bank loan balance falls as you repay, so compare the real papers before deciding.

How do you compare the true costs?

  • Supplier credit: the cost is often the cash discount you give up. If the supplier would take ₹50,000 now or ₹51,000 in 30 days, the price of waiting is ₹1,000.
  • Bank loan: add the interest, fee and any charges, then divide by the months to see the monthly cost. Ask what happens if you repay early.
  • A friend: there may be no rupee cost, but ask what you would give up if you could not repay on time.

What is the cost of lost goodwill?

Goodwill is hard to price but real. If you are late with the supplier, the next order may need cash, which could mean finding ₹50,000 up front instead of paying 30 days later. If you are late with a bank, the record can make the next loan harder. If you are late with a friend, the loss may be larger than any interest.

Before you borrow, ask yourself how sure you are that the stock will sell in time to repay. If you are only fairly sure, choose the source whose failure costs you least.

Which option suits which situation?

  • Supplier credit tends to suit a trusted, regular supplier and a stock turning over within the credit period.
  • A bank loan tends to suit planned, larger purchases where you can wait for the papers and sell over months.
  • A friend can suit a small, short gap, as long as you agree the amount, the date and what happens if it slips, and write it down.

How do you track what you owe?

List each source with the amount, due date and the stock it paid for. Add the dues to your cash plan so that repayments are never a surprise. If you track shop spending in an expense tracker such as SpendixAI, a separate category for loan repayments keeps these payments visible in reports.

A final checklist

  1. Get the real terms from each source in writing.
  2. Work out the extra paid in rupees and per month.
  3. Check that expected sales cover each repayment date.
  4. Add the repayment dates to your cash plan before you borrow.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports