Getting started

Should you categorise by merchant or by purpose?

Should you categorise expenses by merchant or by purpose? Examples where they agree and disagree, and how to handle the cases where they pull apart.

Editorial illustration for Should you categorise by merchant or by purpose?

Categorise by purpose, and let merchants suggest the category as a default. A budget cares about what the money was for, but rules and automatic matching work from merchant text. Where the two agree, such as an electricity bill, you set a rule and forget it. Where they disagree, such as a department store, you accept a default and correct the exceptions.

Two ways to think about a category

A merchant-based category says: this money went to a supermarket. A purpose-based category says: this money bought groceries, or a gift, or school supplies. The merchant is a fact on the statement. The purpose lives in your head.

Rules, history and similar-merchant matching in SpendixAI all work from the merchant, because that is the text on the row. Your budget, though, wants purpose: you set a limit for groceries, not for a particular supermarket. The art is bridging the two.

When they agree

  • Electricity board: always the electricity bill.
  • Broadband provider: always internet.
  • Metro card recharge: always transport.
  • Pharmacy you use for family medicines: mostly health.

For these, a rule is safe. Set it once and every month's row lands correctly.

When they disagree

A large department store sells groceries, clothes, kitchenware and gifts. A big online marketplace sells almost anything. The merchant name tells you nothing about the purpose, and the same payment name could be groceries one week and a birthday present the next.

MerchantPossible purposesSensible default
Department storeGroceries, clothing, household, giftsHousehold, correct exceptions
Online marketplaceElectronics, books, gifts, daily needsShopping, correct exceptions
Petrol pumpFuel, sometimes snacks or car washTransport: fuel
Chemist near homeMedicines, toiletries, baby itemsHealth

Notice that the default is a best guess, not a promise. Your job is to correct the wrong ones, and the corrections become history for next time.

How do I decide the category for an odd purchase?

Ask a simple question: if I stopped doing this, which budget would shrink? If you did not buy that gift, would your gifts line drop? Then it is Gifts, even if you bought it at a hardware shop. If you did not shop for the week, would groceries drop? Then it is Groceries, whatever the store sells. This purpose test settles most arguments with yourself.

Using sub-categories to bridge the gap

Sub-categories let you keep merchant-shaped detail under purpose-shaped parents. Under Household you might keep Kitchen, Cleaning and Repairs. A rule for a hardware shop can point at Household: Repairs, while a department store defaults to plain Household. The parent keeps your budget reports clean and the child keeps the merchant's story.

What should I do in practice?

  1. Write rules only for merchants whose purpose is fixed.
  2. For mixed merchants, set a default category and review them each month.
  3. Correct exceptions, so history learns your pattern.
  4. Use the purpose test for anything that surprises you.
  5. If AI is on, remember it sees the cleaned merchant name and amount band, so it will guess by merchant, not by purpose. Your corrections matter most for these rows.

Accept some imperfection. A category system that is right most of the time and takes five minutes a month beats a perfect one you stop using.

Revisit your defaults after a few months. A merchant that was mostly groceries last spring may be mostly gifts around festival season, and a default that fitted then may now be wrong. A quick look at the biggest mixed merchants each quarter keeps the defaults honest.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports