Tax and GST

Choosing between a spreadsheet, a ledger book and an app for records

Compare a spreadsheet, a paper ledger and an expense app for small business records in India: setup, errors, backup, CA handoff and statement imports.

Editorial illustration for Choosing between a spreadsheet, a ledger book and an app for records

A ledger book suits a very small shop with a handful of entries a day. A spreadsheet suits an owner who is comfortable with formulas and has up to a few hundred entries a month. An app suits anyone who has bank or card statements to bring in and wants the sorting done for them. Many shops end up with a mix, and that is fine.

The right choice depends on how many transactions you have, who else touches the records and how much time you can give each week.

How do the three compare?

QuestionLedger bookSpreadsheetApp
Setup effortNone, buy a bookAn hour to design columnsCreate workspace, add accounts
Typical errorsWrong totals, illegible entriesBroken formulas, overwritten cellsWrong auto-category, duplicate import
BackupPhotograph pages, one copyCloud folder or drive copyStored in your workspace; export copy
Handing to a CAPhotocopies or scansFile sent by emailCSV or export file
Bank statement importTyped by handCopy and paste, then cleanUpload PDF, CSV or Excel
Cash entriesEasyEasyAdd by hand

Which is best for a very small shop?

If you have ten or fewer transactions a day, mostly cash, and your CA is happy with a daily book, a ledger is honest and quick. Its weakness is that it is hard to search and hard to back up. Photograph each page weekly, and keep the photographs in a folder by month.

When does a spreadsheet make sense?

When you want totals by category, month or party, and you can keep a tidy layout. Use one row per transaction with columns for date, amount, category, account and note. A formula such as =SUMIFS($C$2:$C$500, $B$2:$B$500, "Rent") adds the Amount in column C wherever Category in column B is Rent. It works in both Excel and Google Sheets. The risk is silent errors: a dragged formula, a deleted row, a typo in a category name.

When should you move to an app?

When your bank and card statements run to hundreds of rows a month, and typing them in becomes the job. Say you have ₹2,40,000 of monthly spending spread over 300 rows across two accounts. A sheet means 300 rows of copying and categorising each month. An app that imports the statement and suggests categories shifts your effort to reviewing.

SpendixAI takes statements in PDF, CSV or Excel, you review the rows before saving, and each transaction keeps its account. Do not expect every layout to parse perfectly, so check the rows. It does not connect to your bank or read SMS, and Pro covers one personal workspace rather than a team.

What about the CA handoff?

Ask your CA in what form they like to receive records. Many are happy with a clean spreadsheet or CSV. Few enjoy a stack of photographed ledger pages. If you use an app, check that you can export what your CA needs, and ask whether they use Tally, Zoho Books or QuickBooks, since the app offers export templates for these.

A simple recommendation by shop size

  • Cash-heavy shop, under ten entries a day: ledger book, photographed weekly
  • Growing shop, UPI and card payments alongside cash: spreadsheet or app, starting with the bank statement
  • Several accounts, cards and foreign-currency spends: app, since each account and currency is tracked on every row
  • Anyone with a CA who wants a fixed format: ask the CA first, then choose

Before you switch

  1. List how many transactions a month you really have
  2. Decide who will enter or review them, and how often
  3. Run one month in parallel with your old method
  4. Export a copy and open it to confirm it is readable
  5. Keep your old records for the year, and ask your CA how long to retain them
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports