To compare home insurance renewal quotes fairly, put each quote in its own column on one page and list the same rows for each: sum insured, what is covered, what is excluded, the deductible, add-ons and the premium. A quote that looks cheaper may simply cover less, and one page makes that visible in five minutes.
What rows should the sheet have?
Make one row for each line below and one column for each quote, labelled Quote A, Quote B and Quote C, plus a column for your current policy.
| Row in your sheet | What to write in each quote's cell | Where to find it in the quote |
|---|---|---|
| Building sum insured | Rupee amount | Quote summary or schedule |
| Contents sum insured | Rupee amount, or Not offered | Quote summary or schedule |
| Premium before GST | Rupee amount | Premium breakup |
| GST on premium | Rupee amount as shown | Premium breakup |
| Total payable | Rupee amount | Last line of the premium breakup |
| Deductible or excess | Fixed amount or percentage | Terms or schedule |
| Add-ons included | Names of each add-on | Schedule |
| Main exclusions | Your own short summary | Exclusions section |
| Waiting periods | Days, or None stated | Terms |
| Claim process and helpline | How to inform the insurer and how soon | Claims section |
Leave nothing blank. If a quote does not state something, write Not stated and ask the insurer or agent for it in writing.
Why compare cost per lakh of cover?
Two premiums mean little unless the cover is the same. Divide the premium by the sum insured in lakhs to get a rate per lakh. Say Quote A is ₹6,200 for a ₹40,00,000 sum insured and Quote B is ₹5,400 for ₹25,00,000. In lakhs, that is 40 and 25. Quote A works out at 6,200 ÷ 40 = ₹155 per lakh. Quote B works out at 5,400 ÷ 25 = ₹216 per lakh. B has the lower premium, but A gives you more cover for each rupee. These numbers are illustrations, not real prices.
In a spreadsheet, with the premium in C3 and the sum insured in C2, use =C3/(C2/100000). Copy it across to the other quote columns. The formula works in Excel and Google Sheets.
How do you compare inclusions and exclusions?
Read the exclusions of each quote and write them in the sheet in your own words. Look for gaps that matter to your home: water damage from leaking pipes, damage from heavy rain, theft, electrical items, and whether jewellery and valuables are covered or capped. Do not assume two policies with the same name offer the same cover.
- Does the building sum insured reflect the cost of rebuilding, not the market price of the flat?
- Is the contents sum insured close to what it would cost you to replace your belongings today?
- Is any item capped, such as jewellery or electronics?
- Is the deductible a fixed amount or a percentage of the claim?
- Are the add-ons you had last year still included?
What changed since last year?
Add a column for your current policy. Look at the sum insured, the premium and the exclusions. If the renewal premium has increased, ask the insurer what changed. If the sum insured has been lowered or the deductible raised, you are comparing two different products. Do not accept a renewal notice without reading the schedule.
How do you keep the decision on record?
Save the filled sheet with the quotes and the final policy schedule in one folder. When you pay the premium, record it in your expense tracker with the policy number in the note. In SpendixAI, a custom category for home insurance and the premium receipt attached to the transaction keeps the renewal history in one place.
Before you decide
- Every row filled for every quote.
- Cost per lakh worked out for each.
- Exclusions and deductible compared line by line.
- Your current policy added as a baseline.
- Questions sent to the agent in writing, and the answers saved.
- A calm gap before the renewal date, so you are not choosing in a hurry.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports


