Spreadsheets

Where your data lives: expense spreadsheet vs expense app

Where does your expense data live? Compare a local spreadsheet, a cloud-drive sheet and an expense app, and what to check about access, sharing and backups.

Editorial illustration for Where your data lives: expense spreadsheet vs expense app

Your expense records sit in one of three places: a file on your own device, a file in a cloud drive, or an app's servers. Each has a different answer to who can see it, who can lose it and how you take it with you. The safest choice is the one whose sharing, backup and export you actually understand and have checked.

Where does the data sit in each option?

OptionWhere the data sitsWho can reach itWhat to check
Local Excel fileYour laptop or phone storageAnyone using that device, and any copy you emailDevice lock, backup copy, old copies in downloads and email
Sheet in a cloud driveThe provider's servers, plus synced copies on your devicesYou, plus anyone you shared it with, and anyone with a link if link sharing is onSharing list, link settings, signed-in devices, version history
Expense appThe app provider's servers, in your accountYou, plus anyone you invite, and the provider's staff under its policyPrivacy policy, role-based access, export, deletion

Is a cloud sheet safe for finances?

It depends less on the product than on the settings. Many leaks happen because a link was set to anyone who has it and then forgotten. Open the sharing panel, read the list of people and the link setting, and remove anyone who no longer needs access. Also check which devices are signed in. A tablet you sold two years ago can still hold a copy.

What about protecting a local Excel file?

Excel can encrypt a file with a password, under File, Info, Protect Workbook. This is a useful lock for a file you keep on your own machine. Two cautions. If you lose the password, nobody can open the file for you. And the password protects that file only, not the older copies you emailed or left in a downloads folder, so search your own device and mailbox for old versions.

What should you ask an expense app?

  1. Does it ask for my net-banking login? If it does, think hard.
  2. Where do my records live, and who in the organisation can reach them?
  3. Is my data sold or shared for advertising?
  4. Can I export everything, in a format another tool can open?
  5. Can I delete my data, and how long does that take?
  6. If it uses AI, what exactly gets sent to the model, and can I switch it off?

A good app answers these in plain words. If you cannot find the answers, treat that as an answer.

How does SpendixAI answer those questions?

SpendixAI works from statements you upload as PDF, CSV or Excel, so it does not need a bank connection or your net-banking login, and it does not read SMS. Sign-in is through Google only, with no passwords stored for you to forget. Records live in your own workspace with role-based access, and it says it does not sell personal information. Owners can export data, choose how long documents are kept, delete transactions and schedule deletion of the whole workspace with a seven-day window to change their mind. Deleted transactions sit in a recycle bin for 30 days.

For categorisation, an AI step is optional. When on, it uses the normalised merchant name and an amount band, not your name, account numbers, full statement text or balances. Optional features that read an unfamiliar statement layout do process the uploaded document, so switch them off if you are not comfortable with that.

A fifteen-minute privacy check, whichever you use

  • List where copies of your finance data exist: devices, drive, email, backups.
  • Review who has access to each and remove anyone who does not need it.
  • Turn off link sharing unless you need it.
  • Confirm you can export everything.
  • Set a reminder to repeat this every few months.

Rules about financial data and your own comfort with risk are personal. If your sheet holds client or business records, check your obligations with your adviser.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports