Business

Franchise or your own brand: comparing startup costs on equal terms

Comparing franchise and own brand startup costs on equal terms: a sheet for one-time fees, monthly fees and stock rules, with a made-up three-year example.

Editorial illustration for Franchise or your own brand: comparing startup costs on equal terms

To compare a franchise with your own brand, put both on one sheet with the same lines: one-time fees, fit-out, stock rules, monthly fees and a three-year total. Fill the franchise column from the offer document and the own-brand column from your own quotes. The aim is a fair comparison of what each costs you in rupees, before you judge what each is likely to earn.

What should the comparison sheet include?

LineFranchise (from the offer papers)Own brand (your estimate)
One-time franchise or brand feeWrite the amountNil, or your design and registration cost
Refundable depositWrite the amount and termsShop deposit only
Fit-outRequired design and supplier, if anyYour own quotes
Stock rulesMinimum opening order and approved suppliersYour own choice of suppliers
Monthly fee or royaltyFixed amount or share of salesNil
Marketing contributionAmount and what it buysYour own advertising budget
Training and supportWhat is included, and for how longWhat you arrange yourself
Term, renewal and exitLength, renewal cost and what happens if you leaveYour lease terms

Leave a cell blank rather than guess. A blank is a question to ask.

A worked example with placeholders

Every figure here is made up to show the method. Suppose the franchise asks for a one-time fee of ₹3,00,000, requires a ₹4,00,000 fit-out to its design, charges ₹12,000 a month as a fee and takes ₹3,000 a month as marketing contribution. Your own brand needs ₹2,50,000 of fit-out and ₹1,00,000 for launch and signboard, with ₹8,000 a month of your own marketing.

Three-year viewFranchiseOwn brand
One-time fee₹3,00,000₹0
Fit-out and launch₹4,00,000₹3,50,000
Monthly fee, 36 months₹4,32,000₹0
Marketing, 36 months₹1,08,000₹2,88,000
Total over three years₹12,40,000₹6,38,000

Check the franchise column: 3,00,000 plus 4,00,000 is 7,00,000; plus 4,32,000 is 11,32,000; plus 1,08,000 is ₹12,40,000. The own-brand column: 2,50,000 plus 1,00,000 is 3,50,000; plus 2,88,000 is 6,38,000. The difference is 12,40,000 minus 6,38,000, which is ₹6,02,000.

What does that difference tell you?

Divide the difference by 36 months: 6,02,000 divided by 36 is about ₹16,700. In this made-up example, the franchise would need to bring in roughly ₹16,700 more profit every month than your own brand to break even over three years. That does not say the franchise is a poor choice. It tells you what the brand name, the training and the supply chain have to deliver.

Which questions should you ask the franchisor?

  • Who is allowed to sell nearby, and what protects your area?
  • Can you source goods from anywhere else, or only from named suppliers at set prices?
  • What happens to the deposit and the fit-out if you leave early?
  • What will you pay if the franchisor changes the design or the product range?
  • Can you speak to current owners about their actual costs, not only their sales?

How do you keep the comparison honest?

Use the same period, the same city and the same size of shop for both. Include the lines that are easy to forget, such as the cost of a lock-in period, renewal fees and the stock you are forced to buy. If you track real spending in an expense tracker such as SpendixAI after you open, you can compare the sheet with what actually went out.

What about the things a sheet cannot show?

A sheet cannot show footfall, trust in a known name or the value of a ready-made system, and it cannot show the freedom of choosing your own range and prices. Write those down in a short list beside the numbers, and give each a rough weight from your own experience. Then the final decision combines the rupees you can count with the points you cannot.

Next step

  1. Fill the franchise column from the offer document.
  2. Get at least two quotes for the own-brand fit-out.
  3. Work out the three-year total and the monthly break-even difference.
  4. Speak to two current owners about their costs.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports