Debt

Interest or no interest on a family loan: the arithmetic

Should a family loan carry interest? See with sample rupee numbers what the lender gives up and the borrower saves, and how to log it plainly.

Editorial illustration for Interest or no interest on a family loan: the arithmetic

A family loan with no interest costs the lender whatever that money would otherwise have earned, and saves the borrower whatever they would otherwise have paid elsewhere. Whether to charge interest is a family decision, but the arithmetic below shows how big the gap is, so the choice is made with open eyes and not with a vague feeling.

What does the lender give up?

Say you lend ₹2,00,000 for two years to a sibling. If that money would otherwise sit somewhere earning an assumed 6 per cent a year, simple interest is principal times rate times years divided by 100.

  • Per year: ₹2,00,000 x 6 x 1 / 100 = ₹12,000
  • Over two years: ₹12,000 x 2 = ₹24,000
  • Per month, roughly: ₹24,000 / 24 = ₹1,000

The 6 per cent is only an example. Use whatever your own money would really earn, and remember that this is a simplified view; real accounts may compound.

What does the borrower save?

The borrower's saving is whatever the alternative would cost. Suppose the sibling would otherwise borrow from a source charging an assumed 12 per cent a year. Then: ₹2,00,000 x 12 x 1 / 100 = ₹24,000 a year, or ₹48,000 over two years.

So in this example the lender gives up ₹24,000 and the borrower avoids ₹48,000. The two figures differ simply because the two rates differ. With no interest, the family is quietly moving both amounts around, and it is worth knowing that before deciding whether to leave it that way.

What is a fair middle?

Some families pick a figure between the two rates, so the lender is not out of pocket and the borrower still gets a better deal. At an assumed 3 per cent a year the interest on the loan would be ₹2,00,000 x 3 x 1 / 100 = ₹6,000 a year, or ₹500 a month, ₹12,000 over two years.

OptionRate usedInterest per yearOver 2 yearsPer month
No interest0 per cent₹0₹0₹0
Lender's alternative6 per cent₹12,000₹24,000₹1,000
A middle figure3 per cent₹6,000₹12,000₹500
Borrower's alternative12 per cent₹24,000₹48,000₹2,000

All rates here are illustrations. Pick figures that reflect your real alternatives.

How do I log it so it stays clear?

Split the repayment into two parts, because they are different things. The principal you return is not an expense; it reduces what you owe. The interest is a real cost to the borrower and extra money to the lender. If the instalment is ₹10,000 and ₹500 of it is interest, record ₹9,500 as principal and ₹500 as interest.

  • Borrower: one balance owed that falls with each principal payment, and one expense line for interest.
  • Lender: one balance receivable that falls with each principal payment, and one separate line for interest received.
  • Both: the same dates, agreed in a message.

A separate interest line also makes it easy to show a CA what was paid or received, in case you are ever asked. How such interest is treated is not something to guess; ask the CA.

How do we agree it without it feeling transactional?

Say what you are doing and why. A line such as "I would like to pay something so it is fair to you; would 3 per cent work?" gives the lender the choice to say no. A lender who wants to waive it can say so equally simply: "No interest, just pay it back when you can." Either way, put the answer in a message so it is not left to memory.

When should I ask a professional?

If the sum is large, if property is involved, or if either side may need to show the transaction to a bank, tax office or in a family dispute, ask a CA or lawyer. This article is about arithmetic and records, and rules and limits change, so confirm the current position with your CA or the official source.

If you track your own spending, SpendixAI can hold the repayments as a custom category next to your other expenses, which keeps the monthly outgo honest.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports