Travel and vehicles

Is the longer toll-free route actually cheaper? A worked check

Is the longer toll-free route actually cheaper? A worked check of extra fuel, wear and time for a route adding 18 km, and the toll where it stops paying.

Editorial illustration for Is the longer toll-free route actually cheaper? A worked check

The toll-free route is cheaper only when the toll you skip is bigger than the extra fuel and wear of the added kilometres. For a route that adds 18 km, the break-even toll in the example below is about ₹156 each way; below that, paying the toll costs you less. The method matters more than the numbers, so swap in your own.

What is the formula for comparing the two routes?

Extra cost of the free route = extra km x (fuel cost per km + wear cost per km). Then compare it with the toll you avoid. Add the value of the extra time only if you genuinely put a price on it.

  • Fuel cost per km = fuel price per litre / your mileage in km per litre.
  • Wear cost per km = what you set aside for tyres, servicing and parts, per km driven.
  • Net saving of the free route = toll avoided - extra km x (fuel cost per km + wear cost per km).

In a spreadsheet, with extra km in B1, mileage in B2, fuel price in B3, wear per km in B4 and toll in B5: =B5-B1*(B3/B2+B4). A negative answer means the free route costs you more.

What does a worked example look like?

All numbers here are hypothetical. Say the free route adds 18 km. Your car does 15 km/l and petrol costs ₹100 a litre, so fuel is 100 / 15 = ₹6.67 a km. Set wear at ₹2 a km. That is ₹8.67 a km all-in, so the extra 18 km costs about 18 x 8.67 = ₹156.

Say the toll you avoid is ₹85 each way. Then the net saving is ₹85 - ₹156 = minus ₹71. The free route loses by ₹71 a trip, before you count the extra time.

At what toll does the free route start winning?

Toll avoided (one way)Extra cost of free routeNet saving of free route
₹85₹156minus ₹71
₹150₹156minus ₹6
₹200₹156₹44
₹300₹156₹144

The crossover sits at ₹156, the extra cost itself. If your toll is ₹150 you are roughly level, and anything above that favours the free route on cost alone. Doing the return leg on the same road doubles both numbers, so the answer stays the same.

Should I count the extra time?

Only if time costs you something. A longer drive on a Sunday may be free; a longer drive before a 10 am meeting is not. Say the free route adds 25 minutes. If you value that at nothing, ignore it. If you value an hour at ₹150, 25 minutes is about ₹62, which pushes the break-even toll up to roughly ₹218. Use your own figure, and be honest about it.

What else changes the answer?

  • Road condition: a rough free road increases tyre wear, so your wear figure should be higher.
  • Traffic: stop-start driving on the free route burns more fuel than the free-flowing highway.
  • Safety and night driving: a quiet road after dark may not be worth the saving.
  • Mileage differences: highway mileage is often better than your city figure, so use real tank-to-tank data if you have it.

How do I get my own numbers?

Fill the tank, reset the trip meter, drive, then refill. Kilometres driven divided by litres added gives your true mileage. Log fuel and toll entries as you go, and after a few trips you will have real figures instead of guesses. SpendixAI can sort the fuel and toll lines in an uploaded statement into categories so that the monthly totals are easy to read, though the mileage maths still needs your own odometer.

  1. Note the toll on the paid route from your last FASTag deduction.
  2. Estimate the extra km from the map for the free route.
  3. Calculate the extra cost with your own mileage and wear figure.
  4. Decide, and log the actual spend after the trip to check your guess.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports