Cards and UPI

Keep or close a credit card? A checklist from your own data

Should I close my credit card? A checklist built from your own data: yearly cost, benefits used, spend share and subscriptions tied to the card.

Editorial illustration for Keep or close a credit card? A checklist from your own data

Whether to keep or close a credit card comes down to what it costs you, what it gives you, how much of your spending depends on it, and what is attached to it. Answer the questions below from your own statements and you will have a decision based on facts. How closing affects your credit record is a separate question for your issuer or a qualified professional.

What does the card cost you in a year?

Add the annual fee, interest, penalty and other charges from the last twelve statements. Subtract the value of cashback, points and perks you really used. The worksheet for the yearly cost of a card sets this out step by step. Write the net figure at the top of your checklist, and note whether the fee was waived.

How much of your spending runs through it?

Total the card's spending for the year and divide by all your card and UPI spending. Say the card carried ₹80,000 of a household's ₹5,00,000 yearly spending. The share is 80,000 ÷ 5,00,000 = 16%. A small share means closing it changes little. A large share means moving that spending somewhere else, and the rewards or protections that came with it.

  • Card's yearly spend: =SUMIFS($C$2:$C$3000, $B$2:$B$3000, "Card A")
  • Share of total: =that figure / SUM($C$2:$C$3000)

If you also want to know the cost of what you gave up by using this card, compare its rewards with what your next-best way of paying would have returned on the same spend. That comparison is optional, and it needs the effective reward rate worked out from your own redemptions.

What is attached to the card?

Before closing, list everything that charges the card or depends on it.

  • Subscriptions and auto-debits for streaming, software, insurance premiums, utilities or the gym.
  • Instalments or EMIs that are still running.
  • Wallet, UPI or shopping-app links that use the card as a payment method.
  • Reward points, vouchers and benefits that are unused.
  • Outstanding charges and the last statement, which must be cleared.
QuestionWhere to find the answerYour answer
Net yearly costTwelve statements and the cost worksheetWrite it here
Share of spendingYearly spend by cardWrite it here
Recurring payments attachedRepeated merchants on the statementsWrite it here
Unused points or vouchersCard app and your points logWrite it here
Instalments still runningLatest statementWrite it here

Add a last row for anything the card protects or enables that is hard to replace, such as a long-held account that your records show or a purchase protection you rely on. Mark it as your own judgement rather than a number. Not every part of a decision fits in a table, and that is fine.

Is there a middle option?

Sometimes. Ask the issuer whether a variant without an annual fee exists, or whether the fee can be waived on request. Some people keep a card they rarely use, if it costs nothing and holds a long history. Others prefer a short list that is easy to track. Whether closing a card affects your credit record, and how, is a matter to ask the issuer or a qualified professional.

How can SpendixAI help with the data?

With statements imported against each card, a report of spending by account shows the card's share, and repeated merchants on that card tell you what is attached. Add a custom category for fees and interest so the cost side is a single total. Reports are estimates built from what you have uploaded.

The short checklist

  1. Net yearly cost written down.
  2. Share of spending known.
  3. Recurring payments listed and moved.
  4. Points and vouchers used or released.
  5. Closing questions put to the issuer in writing.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports