Business

Own delivery boy: pay per order or fixed salary? Work out the cost

Delivery boy per order vs fixed salary: compare both pay models with made-up quiet and busy week numbers to see which costs less per order at what volume.

Editorial illustration for Own delivery boy: pay per order or fixed salary? Work out the cost

A fixed salary costs the same whether your delivery boy does 5 orders or 50, while pay per order rises with every delivery. So fixed pay is cheaper per order on busy days and costlier on quiet ones, and the break-even is simply the daily fixed cost divided by the per-order rate. Here is how to work out yours.

How do I find the break-even number of orders?

Add up what a day with a fixed-salary rider costs you, then divide by what you would pay per delivery. Take invented figures: a monthly salary of ₹13,000 over 26 working days is ₹500 a day, and say you also pay ₹100 a day for fuel, so the day costs ₹600. If the per-order option is ₹30 a delivery with fuel included, then 600 divided by 30 gives 20 orders. At exactly 20 orders a day, both cost ₹600. Below 20, per-order is cheaper. Above 20, fixed is cheaper.

A quiet week and a busy week, side by side

Say a quiet week averages 15 orders a day for 6 days, and a festival week averages 40. These are made-up counts.

WeekOrders (6 days)Fixed pay costPer-order costFixed cost per order
Quiet90₹3,600₹2,700₹40
Festival240₹3,600₹7,200₹15

The sums: 6 days at ₹600 is ₹3,600 in both weeks. Quiet week per-order cost is 90 times ₹30, which is ₹2,700, so you save ₹900 by paying per order. In the festival week, 240 times ₹30 is ₹7,200, so the fixed salary saves you ₹3,600.

What does idle time cost me?

On a fixed salary, you pay for the hours the rider waits. In the quiet week above, 15 orders is a lot of standing around, and you are paying ₹40 an order. But idle time is not always wasted: a rider on salary can pack orders, put stock on shelves or run to the wholesaler between deliveries. If you can give him that work, the effective cost of his time drops. Write down honestly how many of his hours are really used.

On per-order pay you pay nothing for idle time, but you may find the rider leaves for a job with more orders, rushes deliveries to earn more, or is unavailable at the exact moment a rush arrives.

Is a mix of both a better fit?

Many shops use a smaller base plus a rate per order. Using the same figures: ₹300 a day base plus ₹15 an order, with the rider using his own bike.

  • At 15 orders: 300 plus 225 is ₹525, which is ₹35 an order.
  • At 20 orders: 300 plus 300 is ₹600, the same as the others.
  • At 40 orders: 300 plus 600 is ₹900, which is ₹22.50 an order.

Notice the mix costs less than fixed pay on a quiet day and less than pure per-order pay on a busy one. It also gives the rider a reason to take more deliveries without leaving him with nothing on a slow day. The cost is a slightly more complex record to keep.

What else should I put in the sum?

  • Fuel and bike wear. If the rider uses his own bike, decide who pays for petrol and repairs and write it down.
  • Late-evening or rain deliveries, which may deserve an extra amount.
  • Bag, phone data or a helmet if you provide them.
  • Wrong-address or return trips, which are trips with no sale.
  • Rules about staff pay, minimum wages, and whether a rider counts as an employee depend on your state and your arrangement, so check with your CA or the local labour office before you fix the structure.

Before you decide

  1. Count your actual orders per day for the last two or three weeks.
  2. Compute your own break-even: daily fixed cost divided by the per-order rate.
  3. If most days sit below it, lean towards per-order or the mix. If most days sit above it, fixed pay is cheaper per order.
  4. Try the choice for a month, then compare the real month's cost with this sum.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports