Debt

Phone on EMI vs saving Rs 4,000 a month: month-by-month arithmetic

A ₹48,000 phone on EMI against saving ₹4,000 a month: month-by-month figures, the extra paid, when you get the phone and what it does to your budget.

Editorial illustration for Phone on EMI vs saving Rs 4,000 a month: month-by-month arithmetic

Say a phone costs ₹48,000. Saving ₹4,000 a month gets you the phone after 12 months and costs exactly ₹48,000; an EMI of ₹4,200 for 12 months gets it on day one and costs ₹50,400. The difference is ₹2,400 for having the phone a year sooner. Below is the month-by-month picture, with all numbers assumed.

The schedule, month by month

In the EMI plan you pay ₹4,200 on the same date every month. In the saving plan you move ₹4,000 into a separate pot on the same date every month, and buy at the end. The table shows what has been paid in total by selected months.

After monthPaid on EMI (₹)Saved so far (₹)Phone in hand?
14,2004,000EMI: yes. Saving: no
312,60012,000EMI: yes. Saving: no
625,20024,000EMI: yes. Saving: no
937,80036,000EMI: yes. Saving: no
1250,40048,000Both: yes

Check: 4,200 × 12 = 50,400, 4,000 × 12 = 48,000, and 50,400 − 48,000 = 2,400. The EMI figure assumes interest and fees of ₹2,400 in all; your plan could be higher or lower, and some offers fold the cost into the price.

Who actually pays the ₹2,400?

You do, through the interest or charges that sit inside the instalment. Whenever the EMI total is above the cash price, the gap is the cost of borrowing, and it is worth writing down as a separate line so you can see it. If the two totals are equal, make sure the price on the EMI plan is not higher than the cash price elsewhere.

What does each plan do to the monthly budget?

Say your spare cash after bills is ₹6,500 a month. The EMI takes ₹4,200, leaving ₹2,300. The saving plan takes ₹4,000, leaving ₹2,500. Both squeeze the month in nearly the same way, so cash flow does not decide this one; what decides it is what the phone is worth to you in the next 12 months.

  • Does your current phone still work well enough? If so, waiting costs you little.
  • Does it affect your work or studies? Then months without the new phone have a real price.
  • Would a repair on the old phone cost money anyway? Add it to the waiting side.

What if the phone price drops, or a new model arrives?

The price of a given model may change over a year, but you cannot know the direction in advance, so do not build your plan on it. A model that is replaced by a newer one can also become harder to find at the price you noted. Treat any fall as a bonus and any rise as a risk. If a sale or festival offer would reduce the price of the phone you want, note it down for the month you plan to buy and compare again.

Where to track it

In a sheet, set up a column for month, EMI paid, saving made, and a running total with a formula such as =SUM($B$2:B2) in the third column, copied down. SpendixAI lets you upload your bank statement so the EMI debits and the transfers to your saving pot appear as transactions, and you can set a category like Phone EMI or Phone fund to see the totals.

A short checklist before deciding

  1. Note the cash price and the EMI total, and subtract.
  2. Check how many months of use the EMI gives you before the saving plan would catch up.
  3. Look at your budget after the instalment.
  4. Decide what you will do if one month goes wrong.
  5. Set the first payment date and write it down.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports