When you part-prepay a loan, the lender may let you keep the tenure and lower the EMI, or keep the EMI and shorten the tenure. On the same ₹1 lakh part-payment, shortening the tenure saves much more total interest, while lowering the EMI gives a little monthly breathing room. Which suits you depends on whether you need that monthly relief.
The hypothetical loan
- Loan: ₹20,00,000 over 240 months at an assumed 9% a year, reducing balance.
- EMI: about ₹17,995.
- After 24 EMIs the outstanding principal is about ₹19,21,578.
- You make a one-time part-payment of ₹1,00,000 after the 24th EMI, leaving about ₹18,21,578.
- All figures are invented for illustration. Your lender's schedule will differ slightly.
Option A: keep the tenure and lower the EMI
With 216 months left and ₹18,21,578 outstanding, the new EMI comes to about ₹17,058. That is roughly ₹937 less every month. Remaining interest over those 216 months is about ₹18,62,966, compared with about ₹19,65,238 had you not prepaid at all. So the part-payment saves about ₹1,02,272 of interest.
Option B: keep the EMI and shorten the tenure
If you keep paying ₹17,995, the loan ends after about 191 more months instead of 216, so you finish about 25 months early. Remaining interest is about ₹16,07,505, which is a saving of about ₹3,57,733 compared with no prepayment.
| Item | No prepayment | Option A: lower EMI | Option B: shorter tenure |
|---|---|---|---|
| EMI | ₹17,995 | About ₹17,058 | ₹17,995 |
| Months left | 216 | 216 | About 191 |
| Interest from here | About ₹19,65,238 | About ₹18,62,966 | About ₹16,07,505 |
| Interest saved | None | About ₹1,02,272 | About ₹3,57,733 |
| Monthly cash relief | None | About ₹937 | None |
Why is the tenure option so much better on interest?
Because you keep paying the same large instalment, so principal comes down faster every month and each later month's interest is lower. In option A you are paying less each month, which hands back some of the benefit. The two options use the same ₹1 lakh; the difference is whether the benefit arrives as monthly breathing room or as a loan that ends earlier.
Can you get the best of both?
Often yes, if the lender allows it. Choose the lower EMI, then keep paying your old instalment through a standing instruction, treating the difference as a voluntary extra. You still behave like option B on interest but keep the option to drop back to the smaller EMI in a tight month. Check whether your lender permits an EMI change at all, and whether it asks for a fee or a written request.
What does each option do to the monthly budget?
Take a household whose monthly outgo is ₹70,000, with the EMI inside it. In option A that outgo falls to about ₹69,063, which may not feel like much, but across 216 months the relief adds up to roughly ₹2,02,000 of cash that stays with you instead of going to the lender (937 x 216 = 2,02,392). In option B the outgo stays at ₹70,000, and the benefit appears later: the final 25 EMIs, worth about ₹4,49,875 at ₹17,995 each, simply never need to be paid. Neither number is free money, since each is paid for by the choice on the other side of the table.
How do you choose?
- If your monthly budget is tight, or income is uncertain, the lower EMI has real value.
- If your budget is comfortable and you want the loan gone sooner, the shorter tenure saves more interest.
- If you are unsure, take the lower EMI and keep paying the old instalment for a few months to see how it feels.
- Whichever you pick, record the date and amount and compare the new schedule against what you expected.
Loan terms and tax treatment change, so confirm the details with your lender and, for anything tax-related, with your CA. Your own schedule, not these invented figures, is the one that counts.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports


