Debt

Self-check before taking a new loan: how your ratio would change

Before taking a new loan, add the proposed EMI to your current ones, see the new ratio and the free cash left, and answer three questions first.

Editorial illustration for Self-check before taking a new loan: how your ratio would change

Before you sign for a new loan, add the proposed EMI to what you already pay, divide by your take-home pay, and check what free cash is left each month. The ratio tells you how stretched you would be; the free cash tells you whether an ordinary bad month would break the plan.

The two numbers to calculate

  1. New ratio = (current EMIs + proposed EMI) divided by monthly take-home pay.
  2. Free cash = take-home pay minus all EMIs minus your other monthly costs, including savings you have promised yourself.

Use your records for the second number, not your memory. Rent, groceries, utilities, school fees spread monthly, and fixed savings all count.

A worked example

Say take-home pay is ₹80,000, current EMIs are ₹16,000, and other monthly costs are ₹44,000. You are thinking of a new loan with an EMI of ₹12,000. These figures are hypothetical.

LineTodayWith the new loan
Take-home pay₹80,000₹80,000
Total EMIs₹16,000₹28,000
EMI ratio20.0%35.0%
Other monthly costs₹44,000₹44,000
Free cash each month₹20,000₹8,000

The ratio rose from 20.0 to 35.0 percent. Free cash fell from ₹20,000 to ₹8,000, which is a drop of ₹12,000, or 60 percent of the room you had. The ratio looks like a moderate step; the free cash shows that most of your slack is gone.

What does a bad month do to that picture?

Now add a festival month where spending runs ₹6,000 above normal. With the new loan, free cash falls from ₹8,000 to ₹2,000. A medical bill or a repair of ₹5,000 would then push you into overdraft, card spending or savings. Run your own bad-month test by adding the largest extra cost you saw in the past year, then see what the free cash becomes.

Three questions to ask before you sign

  1. After the new EMI, is my free cash still enough for my usual worst month, or only for an average one?
  2. What exactly will I cut or delay to pay this EMI, and have I written it down with an amount?
  3. If my income stopped, how many months of all my EMIs could my savings cover? Here ₹28,000 a month for three months is ₹84,000.

If you cannot answer the third question in rupees, the loan may be affordable on paper but fragile in practice.

Does the loan bring costs the EMI does not show?

Often it does. A vehicle loan comes with fuel, insurance renewal, servicing and parking. A home loan comes with maintenance and furnishing. Add these to your other monthly costs before you calculate free cash. If the running costs came to ₹5,000 a month, free cash in the example would fall from ₹8,000 to ₹3,000, a very different decision from the one the EMI alone suggests.

Is a ratio under my own ceiling enough?

Not by itself. A ratio can look acceptable while free cash is thin, as above, or while a variable cost such as school fees is about to rise. Compare the new ratio with the limit you worked out for your own household, and look at free cash in rupees side by side.

Where do I find the numbers fast?

The cleanest source is the last three months of statements. If you upload them to SpendixAI, you can review your spending by category and read your monthly costs from real entries, then plug the totals into the table above. Check categories before trusting a total.

  • Take-home pay from the salary credits.
  • Other monthly costs from category totals, averaged over three months.
  • Current EMIs from the recurring debits.

Then wait a few days before you sign. If the numbers still look acceptable after a cooling-off period, you are deciding from the arithmetic and not from the excitement of the purchase.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports