To decide between repairing and replacing an old vehicle, add up the last twelve months of repairs, list the repairs you expect over the next twelve, convert both into a monthly figure and set them against the monthly cost of a replacement. The table is a decision aid, not a verdict. The numbers below are invented to show the method.
What goes into the repair log?
Every repair and service invoice for the old vehicle, with date, odometer reading, what was done and the amount. Do not include fuel and insurance in this log; they continue either way. If you do not have invoices, your statement and the workshop's job card history can fill gaps.
Last year's repairs, made-up
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Clutch replacement | ₹9,500 |
| Battery | ₹5,800 |
| Suspension work | ₹7,200 |
| Two regular services (₹4,500 and ₹4,800) | ₹9,300 |
| Tyres | ₹14,000 |
| Twelve-month total | ₹45,800 |
That works out to about ₹3,817 a month (₹45,800 divided by 12).
What do I expect next year?
Ask your mechanic for a list of parts that are close to the end of life, and add the regular service. Suppose: timing belt ₹8,000, brake pads ₹3,500, two services ₹10,000 and an air-conditioning repair ₹6,000. That is ₹27,500 for the year, about ₹2,292 a month. Treat the projection as a range and add a buffer for things nobody predicted.
How do I compare with a replacement?
Set the monthly costs side by side. Fuel and parking are similar either way, so leave them out and compare only what differs.
| Monthly cost | Keep the old vehicle | Replace it |
|---|---|---|
| Repairs and servicing | ₹2,292 | To be checked with the dealer |
| Loan EMI | ₹0 (loan finished) | ₹16,000 |
| Insurance difference | Baseline | ₹600 more |
| Total that differs | ₹2,292 | ₹16,600 |
On those inputs, the replacement costs ₹14,308 more every month (₹16,600 minus ₹2,292). Selling the old vehicle might bring in, say, ₹1,10,000, which could reduce the loan needed. Plug your own sale estimate into the EMI calculation.
What does the table leave out?
- Downtime and the cost of being without a vehicle on a bad day.
- Safety and reliability, especially on highways.
- Depreciation, which is higher on the newer vehicle in absolute rupees.
- The warranty or free servicing on a new vehicle, if any, which you should check with the dealer.
Do not forget the cost of the downtime itself. Each visit to a workshop can mean a day without the vehicle, and if you have to hire a cab or take a day off, that is a real cost of the old vehicle. Add a line for it in the table, even a rough one, so that the comparison does not flatter the old vehicle.
Keeping the log going
A repair log stays useful only if each bill is entered the week it happens. SpendixAI keeps receipts with their transactions, so a workshop invoice can be attached to the payment and found again when you do this exercise. Categorise repairs under a vehicle sub-category so the twelve-month total is one report away.
It is worth writing the decision table out for the next twelve months as well as the current one. Repair costs for old vehicles tend to bunch: a clutch and a suspension job in the same year, then quiet for a while. Looking at three years of repair totals rather than one gives a calmer picture of whether this year was an outlier.
Before you decide
- Get a second opinion on any big projected repair.
- Ask the loan provider about terms if you are replacing before the loan ends.
- Check what the insurer needs for a transfer or a new policy.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports


