Business

Selling on two marketplaces: comparing real earnings per order

Compare the same product sold on two marketplaces by net earnings per order after fees, shipping, ads, returns and payout delay, using made-up numbers.

Editorial illustration for Selling on two marketplaces: comparing real earnings per order

To see which marketplace pays you more, compare net earnings per order, not the selling price. Start with what the customer pays, subtract the marketplace fee, shipping, packaging, ad spend, a returns allowance and the cost of the product, and then look at how long each payout takes. A higher price on one platform can still leave you with less.

What goes into net earnings per order?

  • Selling price received.
  • Marketplace fee, as a share of the price or a fixed charge.
  • Shipping you pay.
  • Packaging.
  • Ad spend per order, if the platform expects advertising to be visible.
  • Returns allowance: expected returns multiplied by what each one costs you.
  • Cost of the product.

Read each platform's current fee and shipping terms yourself. The figures below are invented.

What does the comparison look like?

The same product costs ₹380 to buy. Platform A lists it at ₹799 and platform B at ₹849. On A, the fee is 15 per cent, shipping is ₹75, returns are 12 per cent and each return costs ₹130 in shipping both ways. On B, the fee is 18 per cent, shipping is ₹60, returns are 6 per cent at ₹120 each, and you spend ₹45 per order on ads. Packaging is ₹20 on both.

LinePlatform APlatform B
Selling price₹799.00₹849.00
Marketplace fee-₹119.85-₹152.82
Shipping-₹75.00-₹60.00
Packaging-₹20.00-₹20.00
Product cost-₹380.00-₹380.00
Returns allowance-₹15.60-₹7.20
Ads₹0.00-₹45.00
Net per order₹188.55₹183.98

Check A: 799 - 119.85 - 75 - 20 - 380 - 15.60 = 188.55. Check B: 849 - 152.82 - 60 - 20 - 380 - 7.20 - 45 = 183.98. Over 100 orders A earns ₹18,855 and B earns ₹18,398, a difference of ₹457.

Does payout delay change the answer?

Yes, because delayed money still has to be funded. Suppose A pays seven days after delivery and B pays twenty-one. B holds your money fourteen days longer per order. On a ₹380 product cost and a made-up cost of money of 2 per cent a month, fourteen days is roughly 380 x 0.02 x 14 / 30 = ₹3.55 per order. It does not change the winner here, but if B's cycle were much longer it could.

What else should you weigh?

  • Volume: a platform with lower earnings per order but twice the orders may earn more overall.
  • Return behaviour: a high-return platform eats time as well as money.
  • Dependence: relying on one platform leaves you exposed if its rules change.
  • Cash flow: faster payouts reduce how much working money you need.

How do you gather the numbers?

Pull a month of payout statements from each platform and take the real fee, shipping and return lines, rather than the rate card. Your bank statement shows the payout credits, and importing it into SpendixAI lets you review those credits by date, though per-order fees and deductions come from the platform's own report.

One more thing to try is changing a single number and seeing what happens. If platform B's ad spend fell from ₹45 to ₹20 per order, its net would rise by ₹25 to ₹208.98 and B would lead by ₹20.43 per order. If platform A's return rate rose from 12 per cent to 20 per cent at the same ₹130 cost, its allowance would become ₹26 and its net would fall to ₹178.15. Small shifts in returns and ads can flip the result, so recheck every quarter instead of settling the question once.

A one-page check

  1. Write the same product's cost and selling price on each platform.
  2. Fill every cost line with real recent figures.
  3. Calculate net per order and per 100 orders.
  4. Add payout days and note the difference.
  5. Decide where to push, and review in three months.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports