Business

Should your shop give udhaar at all? A worked cost example

Is giving udhaar worth it? A worked example with made-up numbers for ten customers: margin earned, cash locked up and the share that never returns.

Editorial illustration for Should your shop give udhaar at all? A worked cost example

Giving udhaar is worth it only when the extra margin it brings is larger than the cost of the cash it locks up plus the share that never returns. With the made-up numbers below, ten regular credit customers leave a shop ₹750 a month better off than a cash-only rule, but if the unpaid share doubles from 5 percent to 10 percent, cash-only wins. Plug in your own figures to see which side your shop is on.

The made-up shop and its ten customers

Say ten regular customers each buy ₹3,000 a month on credit, so credit sales are ₹30,000 a month. Say your margin on these goods is 15 percent, which is ₹4,500 a month. These are invented numbers to show the method; your margin, your customers and your results will be different.

Suppose customers settle after about 30 days. Then on an average day roughly ₹30,000 of your money is sitting in other people's khata pages instead of in stock or in the bank.

What does credit cost you each month?

LineWorkingMonthly amount
Margin earned on credit sales₹30,000 x 15%₹4,500
Cost of the cash locked up (say 18% a year)₹30,000 x 18% / 12₹450
Share that never returns (say 5%)₹30,000 x 5%₹1,500
Net result of giving credit₹4,500 - ₹450 - ₹1,500₹2,550

The 18 percent is only a way to price your cash: it could be what a loan would cost you or what you could earn if the cash were used in the shop. Use your own figure, even if it is a rough guess. The 5 percent unpaid share is a made-up number, the one to watch most closely.

What would a cash-only shop have earned?

Now ask a fair question: if you stopped credit, how many of these ten would still buy for cash? Say four would and six would shift to another shop. Then cash-only sales would be 40 percent of ₹30,000, which is ₹12,000. Margin at 15 percent is ₹1,800, with no cash locked up and nothing unpaid.

OptionMonthly result
Give credit to all ten₹2,550
Cash only (four customers stay)₹1,800
Difference in favour of credit₹750

What happens if more of it goes unpaid?

Change one number. Suppose the share that never returns is 10 percent instead of 5 percent. The unpaid amount becomes ₹3,000, and the net result becomes ₹4,500 - ₹450 - ₹3,000 = ₹1,050. That is below the ₹1,800 of the cash-only option, so credit is now costing you ₹750 a month more than it earns. The difference between a good credit policy and a bad one is often a few percentage points of unpaid balances.

What are the middle options between 'all credit' and 'none'?

  • Credit only for customers with a limit, a phone number and a settlement day.
  • Weekly settlement for daily buyers, so the balance is never more than a few days of buying.
  • Credit for essentials only, cash for items with thin margins.
  • A small deposit or advance for large orders, with the rest on a fixed date.
  • A short credit period, say one week, for a new customer, extended only after payments come on time.

Any of these reduces both the cash tied up and the unpaid share. Try them on the same ten-customer example: if limiting credit cut unpaid from 5 percent to 2 percent, the monthly result would be ₹4,500 - ₹450 - ₹600 = ₹3,450, assuming you lose none of the customers.

Run your own version in 20 minutes

  1. List your regular credit customers and their usual monthly credit purchases from the khata. Total them.
  2. Multiply by your margin for those goods.
  3. Note the average number of days they take to pay and multiply the total by your cost of cash for that period.
  4. Add up what you wrote off or gave up last year, and divide by the year's credit sales.
  5. Guess how many would stay on a cash-only rule, and compute that margin.
  6. Compare. If credit wins only narrowly, tighten limits before you stop it.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports