On the four sample debts in this article, the avalanche method costs ₹2,181 less interest than the snowball method with a ₹5,000 monthly extra, but the snowball closes its first debt in month 3 against month 7. Both clear everything in the same 16 months. All figures are invented and illustrative.
The debts and the rules
Four debts with assumed rates: a phone loan of ₹18,000 at 14 percent, a credit card of ₹40,000 at 36 percent, a bike loan of ₹60,000 at 11 percent and a personal loan of ₹90,000 at 16 percent. Minimums are ₹1,600, ₹2,000, ₹2,800 and ₹3,500. Interest is calculated monthly and rounded to the rupee. In both methods, the freed minimum of a closed debt moves to the next target, and the monthly outgo stays at the minimums plus the extra.
The headline comparison
| Measure | Snowball (smallest balance first) | Avalanche (highest rate first) |
|---|---|---|
| First debt closes | Month 3 (phone loan) | Month 7 (credit card) |
| All debts closed | Month 16 | Month 16 |
| Interest after 6 months | ₹16,219 | ₹15,215 |
| Interest after 12 months | ₹23,892 | ₹22,194 |
| Total interest | ₹25,579 | ₹23,398 |
The gap in interest is ₹1,004 after six months, ₹1,698 after twelve and ₹2,181 at the end. It widens because the avalanche keeps paying down the 36 percent balance while the snowball spends months on smaller, cheaper debts.
Does the extra amount change the gap?
Yes, but not in a straight line. With the same debts and different extra payments:
| Extra a month | Snowball interest | Avalanche interest | Difference | Months to clear |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ₹0 | ₹45,446 | ₹45,425 | ₹21 | 26 |
| ₹2,000 | ₹34,150 | ₹32,135 | ₹2,015 | 21 |
| ₹5,000 | ₹25,579 | ₹23,398 | ₹2,181 | 16 |
| ₹10,000 | ₹18,482 | ₹16,696 | ₹1,786 | 12 |
With no extra, the gap is almost nothing, because the freed minimums do most of the work in either order. The more striking effect is the extra amount itself: moving from ₹0 to ₹5,000 a month cuts interest by roughly ₹20,000 to ₹22,000 and saves ten months, far more than the choice of method does.
What does the table leave out?
It assumes the rates never change and that you never miss a month. In real life a card rate may be revised, an EMI may be refinanced, or an emergency may interrupt the plan. It also says nothing about how you feel at month five. A method that wins on paper but is abandoned in month four loses to one you finish. Treat the interest gap as one input among several.
Which should I choose?
- If you are confident you will stay the course, avalanche saves some interest.
- If you need visible wins to keep going, snowball may be worth its price.
- If you are unsure, a hybrid of the two exists, and costs somewhere in between.
The difference of ₹2,181 here is real money, but it is less than a tenth of the ₹25,579 interest itself. Choosing a method you will actually follow is worth more than choosing the mathematically cheaper one and abandoning it.
How do I run this on my own debts?
- List each debt with its balance, yearly rate and minimum.
- Fix your total monthly payment, minimums plus extra.
- Simulate month by month: interest is balance times rate divided by twelve.
- Run it once ordered by balance and once ordered by rate.
- Compare total interest, the month of first closure and the month all debts clear.
What to record to stay on track
Keep each month's payment and balance somewhere you can check against the lender's statement. If you use SpendixAI to import those statements, each payment stays with its account, so the actual extra paid can be compared with the plan.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports

