Security

What "we do not sell your data" actually means

What 'we do not sell your data' actually means, how selling differs from sharing and processing, and the follow-up questions that give you a real privacy answer.

Editorial illustration for What "we do not sell your data" actually means

'We do not sell your data' means the company does not hand your personal information to another business in exchange for money. It does not tell you who else sees your data, whether it is used for advertising, or how long it is kept. It is one useful sentence, not a full privacy answer.

Many apps use the phrase because it is true and reassuring. Your job is to find out what sits around it.

Selling, sharing and processing: what is the difference?

  • Selling: another company receives your data and pays for it. This is the narrow thing the phrase rules out.
  • Sharing: data goes to another party for any reason, with or without payment, such as an advertising network that gets a device identifier.
  • Processing by a service provider: a host, email sender or payment processor handles data to run the app and is bound to act on the app's instructions.
  • Analytics: usage events, such as which screens you open, are collected to see how the product is used. They may or may not be linked to you.
  • Disclosure by law: a court or authority may demand records, and a policy usually reserves the right to comply.

An app can truthfully say it does not sell your data while still sharing identifiers with an advertising network. That is why the other questions matter.

Why is the phrase not enough on its own?

Because the word 'sell' can be defined narrowly. Some policies exclude sharing with 'partners' from their own definition of a sale. Others promise not to sell but say nothing about using your data to train models or target ads. The phrase also says nothing about retention, deletion, staff access or what happens if the company is acquired.

What should I ask a finance app next?

  1. Who are your service providers, and what can each one see?
  2. Do you share any information, even anonymised, with advertisers or advertising networks?
  3. Is my data used to train any model, yours or someone else's?
  4. Who inside the company can open my records, and is that access logged?
  5. How long do you keep my data after I delete a transaction, and after I close the account?
  6. What happens to my data if the company is sold or merges?

What does a worked example look like?

Say you upload a bank statement to an expense app. The hosting company stores the file. An email provider sends your weekly summary. A payment processor handles the subscription. None of these is a sale, and all of them touch something of yours. A well-written policy names those roles and says what each receives. If it does not, ask.

SpendixAI states that it does not sell personal information. It also explains the rest in specifics: categorisation runs through your own rules and history first, and only if AI is switched on does a model see what is left, using a normalised merchant name and an amount band rather than your name, account numbers, full statement text or balances. AI can be turned off per feature or entirely, and unmatched items are then held for review. Optional features such as reading an unfamiliar statement layout do process the uploaded document, and the product says so. That level of detail is what you want from any provider.

What should I do with the answers?

Answer you getWhat it suggestsSensible next step
Specific names or categories, with purposesThe team has mapped its data flowsProceed with a small upload first
A general reassurance with no detailPossibly a template policyAsk a follow-up and see if a human replies
No reply or a deflectionWeak accountabilityDo not upload sensitive records

Laws and definitions differ between countries and change over time, so for anything beyond personal use, such as business books, ask your CA or adviser to read the terms.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports