Debt

Which credit card to pay first? A worked example with two balances

Which credit card to pay off first? A worked example with two invented balances, comparing an extra ₹5,000 on the higher-rate or smaller card.

Editorial illustration for Which credit card to pay first? A worked example with two balances

If you have a little extra to pay, the arithmetic says to put it on the card that charges the higher rate, because that cuts the most interest. The smaller balance clears sooner if you target it first, though, and that can keep you motivated. The example below runs both ways with invented numbers so you can see the gap and repeat it with your own.

The setup

Say you have two cards. Card A owes ₹80,000 at an assumed 3.5% a month. Card B owes ₹20,000 at an assumed 2.5% a month. Each card needs a fixed payment of ₹3,000 and ₹1,000 a month, and you have an extra ₹5,000. That makes ₹9,000 a month in total. When one card clears, its payment moves to the other, so the ₹9,000 stays constant. There are no new spends. Interest is charged on what is left after each payment. All of this is invented; your statement shows your real rates, which may be quoted yearly. If so, dividing by 12 gives a rough monthly figure.

  • Plan 1: put the extra ₹5,000 on Card A, the higher rate.
  • Plan 2: put the extra ₹5,000 on Card B, the smaller balance.

What do the two plans look like after three months?

After month 3Card A owesCard B owesInterest paid so far
Plan 1: extra on Card A₹62,978₹18,385₹8,363
Plan 2: extra on Card B₹79,053₹2,623₹8,675

Plan 2 nearly clears Card B in the first quarter. Plan 1 chips at the large balance instead. At this point Plan 2 looks tidier, because one card is nearly gone, but Plan 1 has already paid slightly less interest.

How do the plans end?

ResultPlan 1: higher rate firstPlan 2: smaller balance first
Card B cleared in month144
Card A cleared in month1214
All debt cleared in month1414
Total interest paidabout ₹20,832about ₹22,933

Both plans finish together, at month 14, because the same ₹9,000 goes out every month. The difference is in the interest: about ₹2,101 less under Plan 1. That is the price of the satisfaction of closing Card B early. Whether it is worth paying is your call; both are legitimate plans if you stick to them.

What if the rates are almost the same?

Then the choice barely matters and you can go with the one that is easier to stick to. Check each statement for the real rate, because fees and the way interest is calculated can change the picture. For example, a card with a cash withdrawal balance may be charged differently from a card with purchases. Use your own paperwork for the details.

How do you run this for your own cards?

  1. List each card with its balance, monthly rate and the payment it needs.
  2. Add up the total you can pay across all cards each month.
  3. Choose the target card and pay the rest only as required.
  4. Each month, apply interest to what is left after payment, then update the balance.
  5. When a card clears, move its payment onto the next target.
  6. Compare the totals of both plans for two or three months, then pick one and keep it.

A sheet is enough for this. Keep one row per card per month and a column for interest, and you will see within a few months whether your actual balances match the plan. Do not add new spends to either card while you run the plan, or the comparison stops being clean.

Before you decide

  • Check the rate on each statement, not from memory.
  • Confirm that each card's required payment is still being made.
  • Keep the extra amount fixed so the plan is easy to follow.
  • If your income changes, rerun the numbers instead of abandoning the plan.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports