Home and property

Working from your hometown: rent saved against costs added

Compare city rent and commute with hometown costs such as travel for meetings, backup internet and family contributions, using your own twelve months.

Editorial illustration for Working from your hometown: rent saved against costs added

To tell whether working from your hometown really saves money, line up the city costs you would stop paying against the new costs you would start, using twelve months of your own spending. The answer is a yearly rupee difference, and it shows whether the rent you save is bigger than the trips, backup internet and family contribution you add.

Which of your spending lines would actually go away?

Start with your last twelve months of statements and pick out only the lines that change if you leave the city. The obvious ones are rent, the commute, the city's utilities and broadband. Be strict about the rest. Food, phone, subscriptions and loan instalments usually continue wherever you live, so leave them out of the comparison, or you will flatter the move.

Which new costs appear in the hometown?

  • Travel to the city for meetings or office visits, with a stay if needed.
  • A second connection, for example a backup mobile data plan, if the broadband at home drops.
  • Power backup, if outages are common where you will work.
  • What you will give your family each month, if you were not already doing so.
  • Local transport, for example fuel for a two-wheeler.

What does a worked comparison look like?

Here is a made-up monthly comparison. Use your own twelve-month averages instead.

LineCity, per monthHometown, per month
Rent₹22,000₹0
Commute₹1,800₹1,000
Utilities (power, water, gas)₹3,000₹2,000
Home broadband₹800₹800
Backup data plan₹0₹700
Travel for meetings (₹24,000 a year)₹0₹2,000
Family contribution₹0₹8,000
Total₹27,600₹14,500

The difference is ₹27,600 - ₹14,500 = ₹13,100 a month, or ₹13,100 x 12 = ₹1,57,200 a year. The travel line is the sum of ₹24,000 for the year divided by 12, which is ₹2,000. In this example the family contribution takes up much of the rent you saved, and that is the point of doing the sum: a lower rent does not mean a lower total.

Now stress the hometown side. Say meeting travel turns out to be twice what you planned, ₹4,000 a month instead of ₹2,000. The hometown total becomes ₹14,500 + ₹2,000 = ₹16,500, and the difference shrinks to ₹27,600 - ₹16,500 = ₹11,100 a month, or ₹1,33,200 a year. If the move still makes sense at the worse figure, you can trust it more.

What are the numbers you cannot see on a statement?

Some effects will not show in your spending history. Your employer may have a view on remote work from another city, and allowances you receive may change with your location. Ask HR in writing and check with a CA how any change in allowances affects your take-home, because rules differ. Also think about slower career visibility, fewer networking chances and the cost of coming back, none of which a spreadsheet will price.

How do you build the comparison from your statements?

  1. Download twelve months of statements for every account and card.
  2. Tag each row with a category, so rent, commute and utilities can be added up on their own.
  3. Write each yearly total in the sheet and divide by 12 for the monthly figure.
  4. Add the hometown lines using quotes, fares and your family's actual needs.
  5. Compare the two totals, and repeat with a pessimistic set of numbers for the new lines.

SpendixAI can import those statements, categorise them, and let you filter and group a year of spending in its reports before you download the result as CSV. Use that for the city side of the table, and fill the hometown side by hand. Revisit the sheet after three months in the new place and replace each guess with what you actually spent.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports