Breakdowns arrive at bad times
A fridge stops cooling in summer or a laptop will not start before a deadline. Pressure pushes people to the quickest option, which is not always the cheapest. A rule decided in advance takes the heat out of the choice.
Two numbers drive the decision
The first is the repair quote as a share of the price of a comparable new item. The second is the age of the item compared with its normal life.
A common rule of thumb is that if the repair costs more than about half the price of a new equivalent, replacement deserves serious thought. If the item is already in the last third of its expected life, even a lower share may favour replacing. These are guides, not laws, and you should adjust them for your situation.
Work through an example
A washing machine, six years old, expected to last ten, has a fault. A repair costs 4,500. A comparable new one costs 22,000.
- Cost share: 4,500 out of 22,000 is about 20%.
- Age: six of ten years, so four years remain on average.
- Repair cost per remaining year: about 1,125.
A new machine at 22,000 over ten years is 2,200 a year. The repair is cheaper per year of use, provided the machine has no other issues. Repair looks sensible.
Now change the numbers. The machine is nine years old and the repair is 9,000. The share is 41% and only about one year of life remains. Replacement looks sounder.
Other factors
Check whether the manufacturer’s warranty or an extended cover still applies. Check whether spare parts are available and whether the same fault is likely to recur. Consider the efficiency of a new model, which can reduce running costs. Also consider disposal and the effort of installation.
A repair of an item that has had repeated failures is more likely to be money wasted.
Fund the new one while you decide
If replacement is likely soon even after a repair, start a small goal for it. The repair buys time, and the goal builds the money that will make the next breakdown less painful. A few hundred units a month for a year goes a long way.
Recording the decision
Record the repair or purchase against the appropriate category and add a note: “repaired, 4,500, age 6”. Over several items, your notes show which brands and categories need repairs earlier and which last. That is information no brochure contains, and it directly informs what you buy next.
When a quote seems high
If a repair quote surprises you, get a second one from another technician if time allows. The difference between two quotes can be large, and the cost of asking is small. Ask what is being replaced and whether a cheaper part exists. A written breakdown makes it easier to compare, and sometimes the second technician identifies a simpler fault. Do not let urgency stop you from asking, unless the item is essential and a day’s delay would cost you more than the likely saving.
A short checklist for the moment
Ask four questions: how old is it, how much is the repair compared with a new one, is there a warranty, and could a repair fail again soon? Write the answers in two minutes. The choice usually becomes clear, and you avoid the panic purchase that comes from deciding in a hurry.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports

