Whether a car used only at weekends is worth keeping depends on your own numbers: what it costs you in a quarter, divided by the trips you actually took, set against what cabs would have charged for the same trips. Log every trip for three months, add the fixed costs that continue whether you drive or not, and compare. The result is a fact about your life, not a verdict on cars.
What to log for each trip
- Date, destination and distance from the odometer.
- Fuel added, tolls (FASTag deductions) and parking for that trip.
- Who travelled and whether the trip was only possible by car, such as luggage, an elderly parent or an outstation drive.
- A cab quote for the same trip, taken from an app at around the same time of day. Take a screenshot, so you are not guessing later.
Which fixed costs belong in the comparison?
Everything that you pay whether the car moves or not: EMI if any, insurance, the parking space or society charge, periodic servicing and tyres, and any annual charges. Spread yearly items over twelve months. Depreciation is real but hard to measure, so keep it as a separate note rather than mixing it into the cash figure.
A worked example with hypothetical numbers
Say the monthly fixed costs are EMI ₹14,000, insurance spread out as ₹2,000 and parking ₹1,500. That is ₹17,500 a month, or 3 x 17,500 = ₹52,500 for the quarter. Over the quarter, fuel was ₹9,000 and tolls ₹1,200, so running costs were ₹10,200. The quarter's total is 52,500 + 10,200 = ₹62,700.
There were 12 trips: eleven local ones where a cab quote came to about ₹900 each, and one outstation trip with a cab quote of ₹7,000. Cab equivalent is 11 x 900 + 7,000 = 9,900 + 7,000 = ₹16,900.
| Measure | Amount |
|---|---|
| Quarter's total cost of the car | ₹62,700 |
| Number of trips | 12 |
| Cost per trip by car | about ₹5,225 |
| Cab equivalent for all 12 trips | ₹16,900 |
| Gap over the quarter | ₹45,800 |
62,700 divided by 12 is ₹5,225. The gap is 62,700 - 16,900 = ₹45,800. On these invented figures, the car costs much more than cabs would have. Real figures will vary, and your own log will tell you where you stand.
What does the number leave out?
Cab quotes do not capture the convenience of leaving at any hour, carrying a child's equipment or an elderly parent's wheelchair, or driving to places where cabs are scarce. They also ignore how many trips you skipped because a cab felt expensive. Equally, the car number ignores resale value. Write these in a notes column and weigh them yourself.
Could a mix of cabs and occasional rentals work?
Some families look at a middle path: a cab for local trips and a rental for the one or two long drives in a year. Add up what that would have cost over the same quarter from actual quotes, not assumptions, and compare it with the car's quarter total.
Making the log easy
A note on your phone with one line per trip is plenty. If you import your bank or card statement into SpendixAI, fuel, tolls and parking can be grouped in a vehicle category, so only cash items and cab quotes need to be added by hand. That makes the quarter's real cost one report rather than a night with a calculator.
After the quarter
- Total fixed and running costs for three months.
- Divide by the number of trips for a per-trip figure.
- Compare with the cab quotes you saved.
- List what the numbers do not capture.
- Decide whether to keep, share, downsize or sell, preferably with a person you trust.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports

