Business

Ad spend: cost per enquiry rather than cost per click

Clicks are cheap to count and easy to mistake for success. Counting enquiries and customers gives a truer picture of what advertising earns.

Editorial illustration for Ad spend: cost per enquiry rather than cost per click

Clicks are not customers

Online advertising platforms offer a flood of numbers: impressions, clicks, reach, engagement. They are easy to see and seductive. But a click is a person looking, not a person buying. Spending decisions made on clicks alone can drift toward the numbers that look good and away from those that pay.

The numbers that matter are enquiries, quotes and customers.

The three costs

For a month of advertising, work out three figures.

  1. Cost per click: total spend divided by clicks.
  2. Cost per enquiry: total spend divided by messages, calls or forms received.
  3. Cost per customer: total spend divided by customers who actually bought.

Each is larger than the one before, and the last is the one that bears on profit.

Three costs from one month of advertising

MeasureValue
------
Ad spend6,000
Clicks600
Enquiries30
New customers6
Cost per click10
Cost per enquiry200
Cost per customer1,000

If the average customer brings a margin of 2,500 on the first job, the advertising returned 15,000 against 6,000 spent. If the margin per customer is only 800, the same advertising lost money.

Know where enquiries come from

Tracking the source of each enquiry takes discipline. Ask every new contact how they found the business, or use different phone numbers, codes or landing pages for different campaigns. Record the answer in a simple list.

Without this, there is no way to know which adverts to continue.

Compare channels fairly

Different channels produce different quality of leads. A cheap click may bring many curious visitors and few buyers. A more expensive placement may bring fewer, better matched enquiries. Compare channels by cost per customer, not cost per click.

Set a ceiling per customer

From the margin on a typical customer, decide the maximum affordable cost to win one. If a first job yields a margin of 2,500, paying up to perhaps a third of that may be reasonable, depending on repeat business. Having a ceiling turns advertising into a managed trade and not an open tap.

Noting enquiries and customers at month-end

In SpendixAI, a category for advertising with the platform in the note makes monthly spend visible. Add the number of enquiries and customers as a note at month-end. Within a few months, the cost per customer emerges from the records, and the decision to cut, hold or raise spending rests on evidence.

Stopping an advert that does not work

It is hard to turn off an advert after investing effort in it. A rule written in advance helps: if the cost per enquiry stays above a set level after a set spend, the advert stops. The rule turns a stressful decision into a procedure.

Note why each advert was stopped, and what replaced it. Over a year, these notes form a personal guide to what works for this particular business and audience, which is worth more than generic advice.

Linking ad spend to the books

Match each month’s ad bill to the sales recorded for the same period, and note the lag between enquiry and sale. Many jobs close weeks after the first contact, so the full return from one month’s spend may show up in the next. Track enquiries by month of arrival and sales by month of close, and look at the quarter as a whole before drawing conclusions.

Aligning ads with stock and capacity

Advertising a product that is out of stock, or driving more orders than the business can serve, wastes money and damages trust. Check stock levels and capacity before launching a campaign, and agree a limit on orders per day that can be handled well. A modest, well-served wave of customers builds a better reputation than a flood that overwhelms the team.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports