Life events

Annual recharge or monthly recharge: work out the break-even

Compare an annual mobile or broadband plan with repeated shorter plans using your own prices: yearly cost, the 28-day trap and a quick formula.

Editorial illustration for Annual recharge or monthly recharge: work out the break-even

To compare an annual recharge with monthly ones, multiply the shorter plan's price by the number of times you will recharge in a year and set that against the long plan's price. Count recharges by validity days, not by calendar months: a plan that lasts 28 days comes round a little over thirteen times a year, not twelve. Use the prices shown in your own app on the day you decide.

Why does a 28-day plan cost more than it looks?

People say monthly, but a plan's validity is counted in days. Divide 365 by the plan's validity to find how many times you will pay. For 28 days that is 365 ÷ 28 = 13.04, so thirteen recharges cover 364 days and a fourteenth falls due a day later. For a 30-day plan it is 365 ÷ 30 = 12.2, so twelve recharges cover 360 days and the thirteenth is needed for the last five.

A worked mobile example

Use invented prices and swap in your own. Say a 28-day plan costs ₹299 and a 365-day plan with similar benefits costs ₹3,599.

ItemCalculationResult
Recharges in a year on the short plan365 ÷ 28, rounded down13 recharges cover 364 of 365 days
Cost on the short plan13 × ₹299₹3,887
Cost on the annual planOne payment₹3,599
Difference₹3,887 − ₹3,599₹288 less on the annual plan

That ₹288 is the saving only if the two plans really give you the same data, calls and extras for the full year, and only if you stay on that number and operator. Read the benefits, daily data limits and any bundled app subscriptions on each plan page, because they change what you are comparing.

Does the same sum work for broadband?

Yes, with the billing cycle in months. Say a monthly broadband plan costs ₹849 and the yearly option costs ₹9,000. Twelve monthly bills come to 12 × ₹849 = ₹10,188, so the yearly option is ₹1,188 cheaper on paper. Then ask what you give up: you pay ₹9,000 at once, and moving house or switching provider before the year ends may mean losing part of it. Check refund and shifting terms with your provider.

In a sheet, put the short plan's validity in days in B1, its price in B2 and the annual plan's price in B3. Then =ROUNDDOWN(365/B1,0)*B2 in B4 gives the yearly cost of the short plan, and =B4-B3 shows the difference.

What should you check before paying for a year?

  • Will your usage stay the same, or are you likely to need more data later?
  • Is the annual plan's price likely to rise, leaving you locked into an old price or missing an upgrade?
  • Can you change the plan midway, and is there a refund if you cannot?
  • If your number is a second SIM, will you still use it in month ten?
  • Does paying a lump sum strain your month's cash flow?

Is the long plan ever worse?

It can be, in three cases. If you may switch operators or move cities within the year, you risk paying for months you will not use. If you only use the connection in some months, a short plan taken only when needed costs less. And if you are not sure the plan suits you, a short test costs less than a yearly mistake.

Keeping a record so you can compare again

Note each recharge in a sheet with the date, plan validity, amount and the payment route, and mark the next-due date. If recharges come through UPI or a card, they show up in statements as a merchant name and amount, which makes it easy to total a year. SpendixAI can keep those entries under one category after you import a statement, so a twelve-month figure is a filter away.

A short decision list

  1. Write down the short plan's price and validity in days.
  2. Work out how many recharges fit in 365 days.
  3. Multiply to get the yearly cost.
  4. Compare with the annual price, after checking the benefits match.
  5. Decide, and diarise the next review date.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports