A spreadsheet is the better choice if you enjoy building it and your spending fits in a few hundred rows a year; an app is the better choice if the effort of entering and sorting rows is what makes you quit. Both work, and the real test is which one you will still be updating when the April to March financial year ends.
What does a spreadsheet do well?
It is free, flexible and fully yours. A simple tracker has a date, an amount, a category and a note. To total a category you can use, in Excel or Google Sheets, =SUMIFS($C$2:$C$500, $B$2:$B$500, "Food"), where column C holds amounts and column B holds categories. To limit it to one month, add date criteria: =SUMIFS($C$2:$C$500, $B$2:$B$500, "Food", $A$2:$A$500, ">="&$E$1, $A$2:$A$500, "<="&$E$2), with the first and last day of the month in E1 and E2. SUMIFS takes the range to add first, then pairs of range and condition.
Where does a spreadsheet start to hurt?
- Every row has to be typed or pasted, and bank statements rarely paste cleanly.
- Categories drift: Swiggy in one row, swiggy order in the next.
- Cash and UPI spends get forgotten unless you enter them that day.
- Formulas break when someone inserts a row outside the range.
Say you spend six minutes a day logging expenses. That is 6 × 30 = 180 minutes, or three hours, a month. If an import and review takes forty minutes, you have bought back about two hours twenty, which is real only if you use the time.
What does an app add and what does it take away?
An app like SpendixAI reads statements uploaded as PDF, CSV or Excel, lets you review the rows before saving and categorises them using your rules, then your history and similar merchants, then an AI model only if you have it on. It also gives a dashboard, a library of 25 ready-made reports and CSV exports. What it takes away is some flexibility: you work with its categories and reports rather than any layout you like. It has no bank connection and does not read SMS, so cash needs manual entry.
How do you choose?
| If you... | Lean toward |
|---|---|
| Like formulas and have under about 30 transactions a month | Spreadsheet |
| Have a card and an account with 100 or more rows a month | App with statement import |
| Share a sheet with a partner who edits it | Spreadsheet, for now |
| Want a GST estimate by category | App with category tax settings |
| Worry about uploading documents anywhere | Spreadsheet on your own device |
When SpendixAI is not the right fit
If you want a perfect custom layout, complete control over formulas, or a tool you can run with no uploads at all, a spreadsheet will serve you better. The app also does not split bills or sync with your bank.
What about a hybrid?
Many people end up with both. They let an app do the import and the categorising, then export a CSV once a month into a sheet for their own charts or year-end notes. That keeps the sheet small and the effort low, and the sheet still holds your own formulas, such as a running total for the financial year from April to March.
A simple way to switch
- Export your sheet as CSV and keep a copy.
- Upload one statement to the free plan.
- Compare category totals with your sheet for that month.
- Keep the sheet as a backup until a full month matches.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports
