Travel and vehicles

Car vs cab vs metro for a 15 km daily commute: a worked comparison

Car, cab or metro for a 15 km daily commute? A worked monthly comparison for one hypothetical commuter over 22 working days, with a table to reuse.

Editorial illustration for Car vs cab vs metro for a 15 km daily commute: a worked comparison

On the hypothetical numbers below, a 15 km commute over 22 working days costs about ₹8,200 a month by car, ₹11,000 by cab and ₹3,100 by metro with an auto at one end. Your answer will differ, because fuel prices, fares and parking vary by city and by building. What carries over is the structure: count every line, not just fuel or the ticket.

What are the assumptions for this commuter?

One person, 15 km each way, 22 working days a month. That is 30 km a day and 660 km a month. Every price below is made up for the exercise and should be replaced.

  • Car: 14 km/l, petrol at ₹100 a litre, office parking ₹1,500 a month, running and depreciation set at ₹3 a km.
  • Cab: ₹250 a ride, two rides a day.
  • Metro: ₹40 a ride, plus an auto of ₹30 for the last stretch on each trip.

How do the three modes compare?

Cost lineCarCabMetro
Fuel or fares₹4,714 (660 km / 14 x ₹100)₹11,000 (44 rides x ₹250)₹1,760 (44 rides x ₹40)
Parking₹1,500₹0₹0
Wear and depreciation₹1,980 (660 km x ₹3)₹0₹0
Last mile₹0₹0₹1,320 (44 x ₹30)
Monthly total₹8,194₹11,000₹3,080
Per working day₹372₹500₹140

The car's fuel line: 660 / 14 = 47.14 litres, times ₹100 = ₹4,714. Per working day, ₹8,194 / 22 = about ₹372.

What is missing from this comparison?

Fixed costs that you pay whether or not you drive: insurance, any EMI, and annual road tax. They are left out on purpose, because they do not change with how you commute, but they do matter if you are deciding whether to own a car at all. Add a monthly share if that is your question.

Also missing is comfort. A cab or car gives a seat, air conditioning and a door-to-door ride; the metro gives a predictable travel time and a walk at each end. Score these yourself, which is why the comparison belongs in a spreadsheet rather than a verdict.

What if I only go to the office three days a week?

Fixed lines stay put while variable lines shrink. Parking may be a monthly pass that costs the same however often you park; fuel and fares fall with the number of trips. Recalculate with your real number of days. With 12 office days instead of 22, the metro's fares and autos scale down to 24 rides x (₹40 + ₹30) = ₹1,680, but a ₹1,500 parking pass for the car would not shrink at all.

Where can I get my own figures from?

Your bank or card statement already holds most of them: fuel stops, parking payments, metro card top-ups and cab payments. SpendixAI can import that statement and group the rows into categories you can review before saving. Create sub-categories such as Commute - fuel, Commute - parking and Commute - fares, and the monthly report lays out the comparison above using your own money.

One more check is the weekly pattern. If you take the car on four days and the metro on one, your monthly figure sits between the two columns, not in either. Multiply each mode's per-day cost by the days you really use it and add them. For example, 17 car days at ₹372 plus 5 metro days at ₹140 comes to ₹6,324 + ₹700 = ₹7,024. Mixed commuting is common, and the table makes it easy to price.

A short checklist before you switch

  1. Total last month's real commute spend, line by line.
  2. Add the fixed costs you would still pay if you stopped driving.
  3. Time one week of the alternative route door to door.
  4. Try the cheaper mode for one month and compare the actuals with this estimate.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports