With the made-up numbers below, a bike costs about ₹4,578 a month while the EMI runs, against ₹2,420 for metro with a short auto ride. Once the EMI ends, the bike drops to ₹1,778 and wins. The number of office days changes the picture too, so there is a sensitivity table further down.
What is the setup for the sample?
10 km each way, so 20 km a day. 22 office days gives 440 km a month. Say the bike does 45 km/l and petrol is ₹100 a litre. Everything here is hypothetical; replace it with yours.
What does the bike really cost?
- Fuel: 440 km / 45 = 9.78 litres, times ₹100 = about ₹978.
- Service and tyres: say ₹6,000 a year, so ₹500 a month.
- Office parking: say ₹300 a month.
- EMI share: say ₹2,800 a month while the loan runs.
Bike total with the EMI: 978 + 500 + 300 + 2,800 = ₹4,578. Without the EMI: ₹1,778.
What does the metro option cost?
Say each metro ride costs ₹35 from a card top-up, and you need 44 rides. That is 44 x 35 = ₹1,540. Add an auto for the last stretch once a day at ₹40, which is 22 x 40 = ₹880. Metro total: ₹2,420.
Top-ups appear on a statement as lump sums, not rides, so count your rides from the card's own history or from the days you actually went.
How does the answer change with fewer office days?
| Cost line | 22 office days | 12 office days |
|---|---|---|
| Bike fuel | ₹978 | ₹533 |
| Bike service, parking and EMI | ₹3,600 | ₹3,600 |
| Bike total | ₹4,578 | ₹4,133 |
| Metro rides | ₹1,540 | ₹840 |
| Last-stretch auto | ₹880 | ₹480 |
| Metro total | ₹2,420 | ₹1,320 |
Fuel per day is about ₹44 (20 km / 45 x ₹100), so 12 days is about ₹533. Service, parking and the EMI are held fixed here because a monthly parking pass and an EMI do not shrink when you go in less. The gap widens in metro's favour as office days fall, because it is mostly variable cost.
What is not in these numbers?
- Insurance renewal and any road-side costs, which fall unevenly through the year.
- Helmet, rain gear and your safety comfort on the road you ride.
- Time: the bike may be quicker door to door on some routes and slower on others.
- Weekend use. If the bike also serves errands, charge only part of the fixed costs to the commute.
When does the bike win outright?
Once the loan is cleared, the bike's fixed lines shrink to service, parking and insurance, and its cost per office day falls to about ₹81 (₹1,778 / 22) against ₹110 for the metro (₹2,420 / 22). With the EMI still running, the bike is ₹208 a day. That is why the loan end date is the most useful number in the whole comparison. Write it at the top of your sheet and rerun the table the month after the last EMI.
A second case where the bike wins is a route the metro does not serve well, where the last stretch becomes two autos and a long walk. If that is your situation, raise the auto line in the metro column before comparing.
How do I get my own figures?
Import last month's statement and look at fuel, parking and metro card lines. SpendixAI lets you create sub-categories for each and shows the totals, with CSV download if you want to move the numbers to a sheet. The service share and the EMI will not be in a fuel line, so add them as monthly entries.
- Record your real office days for a month.
- Fill each line of the table with your own amount.
- Run it again for the month you go in least.
- Decide, then recheck after three months.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports

