Money basics

Co-payment and deductible, worked through with an example

These two terms decide how much of a bill falls to you. A small worked example shows how each behaves and how to budget for the share you pay.

Editorial illustration for Co-payment and deductible, worked through with an example

Two words, two different mechanisms

Health policies often include terms that shift part of a claim back to the policyholder. A co-payment is a share of each eligible claim that you pay, usually a percentage. A deductible is a fixed amount that you bear before the insurer starts paying. They can occur separately or together, and different policies apply them in different ways.

Everything below uses made-up figures to show the arithmetic. Your policy will have its own terms, so read the schedule or ask the insurer.

Co-payment example

Suppose a policy has a co-payment of 10 percent and an eligible bill of 50,000 units. The insurer pays 90 percent, which is 45,000, and you pay 5,000. If the bill is 200,000, your share rises to 20,000. The percentage means that larger bills produce a larger personal share.

Deductible example

Now suppose a policy has a deductible of 30,000 and a sum insured of 400,000. For a claim of 50,000, you pay the first 30,000 and the insurer pays the remaining 20,000. For a claim of 200,000, you still pay 30,000 and the insurer pays 170,000. The deductible is fixed, so its relative effect shrinks as bills grow.

BillCo-payment 10% (you pay)Deductible 30,000 (you pay)
50,0005,00030,000
100,00010,00030,000
200,00020,00030,000

What the table teaches

For smaller bills, a percentage co-payment can mean a lower personal share than a fixed deductible. For large bills, the reverse may be true. Neither is simply better; the choice depends on the sizes of bill you expect, and on how much the lower premium attached to such terms saves you each year.

Budgeting for your share

Once you know the terms, set aside a reserve equal to the likely personal share for a plausible bill. If the deductible is 30,000, then 30,000 should be available in liquid form. Without it, the insurer’s promise to pay the rest may not help in practice, because the first part must be found quickly.

Record it clearly

When a claim is settled, record the full bill, the insurer’s payment and your share as separate figures. This lets you see over time how much the terms actually cost you, and compare that with the premium savings they provide.

Always check the exact definition in the policy, since the order in which limits, co-payments and deductibles are applied can differ. A short question to the insurer, answered in writing, is worth more than an assumption.

Comparing policies using the terms

When comparing two policies, put the co-payment and deductible terms next to the premium. A policy with a lower premium and a high deductible may suit a household that holds a solid reserve. A policy with a higher premium and no such terms may suit one that prefers predictable out-of-pocket costs. Neither is better on paper; the fit depends on your reserve and your comfort.

Try the same bill sizes on both. A table with three sample bills and the amount you would pay under each policy turns an abstract comparison into something concrete, and it is a handy page to take to an adviser.

Where the two meet other terms

Co-payments and deductibles rarely act alone. A policy may also have a room rent limit, sub-limits and exclusions that change the amount payable before the co-payment is applied. The order in which these are applied can matter, so ask the insurer to show a sample calculation using a realistic bill. Keep the sample with your policy papers.

If the insurer cannot give a sample, ask for the clause that sets out the order and read it with care. A calculation you have tested is far more reliable than a general impression of how the policy behaves.

Voluntary versus compulsory

Some policies let you choose a voluntary deductible or co-payment in exchange for a lower premium. Treat that as a deliberate trade: you accept more of the risk in exchange for a lower price. Make sure you hold a reserve at least equal to the extra amount you are agreeing to bear, otherwise the saving on the premium is a false economy.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports