Life events

Compare three flats: rent, deposit, commute and upkeep on one sheet

Compare flats before renting on one sheet that turns rent, deposit, brokerage, commute and maintenance into a monthly cost for each, using your own commute data.

Editorial illustration for Compare three flats: rent, deposit, commute and upkeep on one sheet

To compare flats before renting, turn every cost into a monthly figure on one sheet: rent, extra maintenance, commute, brokerage spread across the months you will stay, and a small cost for the deposit that is locked up. The flat with the lowest rent is often not the flat with the lowest monthly total.

What goes into the monthly-equivalent?

  • Rent plus any maintenance or society charge that is not included.
  • Commute: the real monthly cost of getting to work, by bus, metro, auto or two-wheeler.
  • Brokerage divided by the number of months you expect to stay.
  • The deposit, which is returned later but cannot be used meanwhile.
  • Other recurring costs that differ: parking, water, a cook or a maid.

How do you cost the deposit?

A deposit is refundable, so it is not a cost the way rent is. But money locked away for years cannot earn anything. A simple way is to look at what your own savings would earn on that amount in a year, using your own bank's statement, and divide by twelve. For this worked example, I use a made-up figure: say each ₹1,00,000 would earn ₹3,000 a year, which is ₹250 a month.

What does a three-flat sheet look like?

The numbers below are hypothetical. Assume you will stay for twenty-four months.

Line (monthly, ₹)Flat AFlat BFlat C
Rent18,00016,00020,000
Maintenance not included01,5000
Commute3,3005,5001,100
Brokerage / 24 months750 (18,000 / 24)0833 (20,000 / 24)
Deposit locked: amount90,0001,60,00060,000
Deposit cost at ₹250 per lakh225400150
Monthly equivalent22,27523,40022,083

Check Flat A: 18,000 + 3,300 + 750 + 225 is 22,275. Flat B: 16,000 + 1,500 + 5,500 + 400 is 23,400. Flat C: 20,000 + 1,100 + 833 + 150 is 22,083 after rounding. In this example, the cheapest rent, Flat B, ends up the most expensive overall, and the dearest rent, Flat C, ends up the cheapest.

What else deserves a column?

The sheet works in rupees, but a flat is more than that. Add a short notes column for things you cannot price: natural light, noise, water supply through the day, nearby grocery shops, a safe walk at night, the landlord's response when you called. Rate each from one to five if that helps you decide. Then use the monthly total and the notes together, not either alone.

How do you build it from your own numbers?

Take rent and deposit from the listing or the broker's message, and the commute from your own travel records. If you use SpendixAI, your imported statements show what you currently spend on commute and maintenance, which helps you set realistic figures for the new places. It cannot tell you the rent, so those numbers come from the flat owner.

Is a lower monthly cost always the better flat?

Not necessarily. A flat that is cheaper by a few hundred rupees but adds an hour to your day may not be a bargain, and a dearer flat near work may give you time back. Use the sheet to see the money, and your own judgement to weigh the rest. If two flats are within a few hundred rupees of each other, let the notes decide, because the sheet's figures rest on estimates.

Before you choose

  1. Enter the three candidates with rent, deposit, brokerage and the maintenance not included.
  2. Fill the commute line from a real trip, not a guess.
  3. Choose a stay length and divide brokerage by it.
  4. Add the deposit cost with your own figure.
  5. Compare the totals, then read the notes before you decide.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports