Money tips

Is the AI in your expense app worth its cost? Run a two-month test

Decide whether AI categorisation earns its keep by running one month with it off and one with it on, then weighing minutes saved against euros spent.

Editorial illustration for Is the AI in your expense app worth its cost? Run a two-month test

You do not have to guess whether AI features in an expense app are worth paying for. Run the app for one month with AI off and one month with it on, measure the review time and the cost, and compare. The euro figures below are invented, but the method works with your own.

What do you measure in the first month?

Turn AI off. Import your statements as usual and count the transactions the tool could not categorise from your rules and history, and time how long it takes you to fix them. Suppose 90 items remain and each takes you 20 seconds. That is 1,800 seconds, or 30 minutes.

What do you measure in the second month?

Turn AI on, with a monthly ceiling, and import a similar month. Count how many items still needed your attention, and check the usage and cost. Suppose 20 items remain at 20 seconds each, which is 400 seconds, about 6.7 minutes, and the usage cost is €0.70.

MeasureAI offAI on
Items you fixed by hand9020
Time spent30 minutes6.7 minutes
AI cost€0€0.70
Time savednoneabout 23 minutes

About 23 minutes saved for €0.70 is roughly 3 cents a minute (0.70 divided by 23). Whether that is worth it is for you to say, but now you are deciding on numbers instead of a feeling.

What could make the comparison unfair?

  • A heavier month in one of the two periods, which means more items to categorise.
  • A new rule you added in the second month, which would have reduced the work even without AI.
  • A back-catalogue import in the first month, which inflated the count of unfamiliar merchants.
  • Accuracy: items the AI got wrong and you had to fix later.

To be fair, count the corrections too. If the AI categorised 70 items and you had to fix 8, the net time saved is lower than the headline.

What data does the feature use?

This matters as much as cost. Find out what the AI receives: only a merchant name and amount band, or the whole statement text, your name and account numbers. A feature that sends less is easier to trust, and a feature that cannot tell you what it sends is a reason to leave it off.

What if the test says AI is not worth it?

Then leave it off and invest the same time in rules. Every rule you write removes a merchant from the pile for good. After a few months of rules and corrections, the remaining pile can be small enough that even a free manual review takes a few minutes.

Repeat the test every six months. As you add rules, the share of items that need AI falls, so a feature that earned its keep in your first month can become nearly idle in your eighth. The reverse also happens: a new account, a change of bank or a new kind of spending can bring a wave of unfamiliar merchants, and the AI is useful again. Treat the answer as a seasonal one, not a permanent verdict.

A note on SpendixAI

SpendixAI is built around India and INR, so we are not suggesting it for euro households. For rupee users, it describes staged categorisation (your rules, then your history, then AI only for what is left) with the AI switchable per feature or entirely, and a monthly AI budget.

Your test plan

  1. Month one: AI off, count and time the manual fixes.
  2. Month two: AI on with a ceiling, count, time and cost.
  3. Compare minutes saved against euros spent.
  4. Keep it, narrow it or switch it off.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports