Cashback and reward offers can make you spend more, because a small return feels like a reason to buy something you would not otherwise have bought. You can check this for yourself by comparing the months you chased offers with the months you ignored them, using your own category totals instead of how it feels.
Why can an offer raise spending?
A reward is a small gain, so a purchase feels cheaper than it is. Spending ₹2,000 to earn back ₹100 is still spending ₹1,900. Offers can also change the basket: you add an item to reach a minimum order value, buy a bigger pack, shift a purchase forward to catch a date, or choose a category because it carries extra points. Each step is small and sensible on its own. Added together, they can push the month up.
This does not mean offers are bad. If you were going to buy the item anyway, a discount is simply a discount. The question is whether the offer changed what or how much you bought.
The self-test
- Pick six months of your records. Mark each month as an offer-chasing month or a quiet month, based on how much you used cashback apps, reward-points bonuses and sale events.
- For each month, take the total spending and the total in the categories most touched by offers, such as shopping, electronics, dining and travel.
- Remove one-offs and fixed costs like rent, so they do not hide the difference.
- Compare the averages of the two groups of months.
- Add the value of the rewards you earned in the chasing months, and subtract it from the extra spending.
A worked example with made-up numbers
Say that in three offer-chasing months your spending in the offer-sensitive categories averaged ₹22,000. In three quiet months it averaged ₹16,500. The rewards you earned in the chasing months averaged ₹700 a month.
| Measure | Chasing months | Quiet months |
|---|---|---|
| Average spend in offer-sensitive categories | ₹22,000 | ₹16,500 |
| Extra spend | ₹5,500 | None |
| Average reward earned | ₹700 | About ₹100 |
| Extra spend minus reward gain | ₹4,800 | - |
The extra spending is ₹22,000 minus ₹16,500, which is ₹5,500. Taking off the ₹700 of rewards leaves a net extra of ₹4,800 a month. If your own numbers look like this, the offers are costing you, even though each reward felt like a gain. If the difference is close to zero, you are using offers without letting them steer you.
What should I look at in my category totals?
- Number of purchases, not only the total. More small purchases suggests topping up baskets for a threshold.
- Average basket size in the months of sales.
- New merchants that appear only in chasing months.
- Items bought and then returned or unused.
- Anything bought in the last two days before an offer ended.
If the offers are costing you
Use offers only for items on a list you made before you saw the offer. Check the effective price against the price you would have paid at a normal time. Skip any step whose only purpose is reaching a minimum. If a card's reward scheme pushes you towards a category you do not need, consider whether the reward is worth the extra swipes. Terms change, so read the current terms on your own card or app.
The test needs month-by-month category totals, and SpendixAI can supply them from your imported statements through its category reports and Report builder, with CSV download if you want to chart the comparison in a spreadsheet. You still mark which months were chasing months yourself.
Your next step
- Mark the last six months as chasing or quiet.
- Work out the net extra spend using the steps above.
- Decide on one rule, such as buying only from a pre-made list when an offer is on.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports


