Life events

Gujiya and thandai at home: an ingredient cost list

Work out the cost per gujiya and per glass of thandai from your own ingredient bills, including gas and oil, and compare it with buying them ready-made.

Editorial illustration for Gujiya and thandai at home: an ingredient cost list

To find the cost of one gujiya or one glass of thandai, add up the ingredient bills for the batch, add a share for gas and oil, and divide by the number of pieces or glasses. Then compare that number with the price of a ready-made one. The prices below are made up, so replace them with the ones on your own receipts.

What goes into a batch of gujiya?

Say one batch makes 30 gujiyas. Gujiya needs a dough of flour and fat, and a filling of khoya, sugar and dry fruits, then frying or baking. Keep the receipts for each item and count only what the batch actually uses.

ItemCost for the batch
Flour for the dough₹60
Khoya₹360
Sugar₹50
Dry fruits and cardamom₹150
Oil or ghee used for frying₹250
Gas₹40
Total, cash cost₹910

Check: 60 + 360 + 50 + 150 + 250 + 40 = 910. Divide by 30 and each gujiya costs about ₹30.33. If you value three hours of your time at ₹100 an hour, add ₹300, making ₹1,210, or about ₹40.33 a piece.

What about a glass of thandai?

Say a batch makes 12 glasses. You need milk, sugar, nuts and seeds, a few spices and rose petals, plus a little gas to boil the milk.

ItemCost for the batch
Milk, 3 litres₹180
Sugar₹40
Nuts and seeds₹220
Fennel and other spices₹60
Rose petals₹40
Gas₹15
Total₹555

The sum: 180 + 40 + 220 + 60 + 40 + 15 = 555. Dividing by 12 gives about ₹46.25 per glass. In your sheet, put the batch cost in B2 and the yield in B3, and the unit cost is =B2/B3.

How does it compare with buying?

Say a shop sells a gujiya at ₹55 and a glass of thandai at ₹80. On cash cost alone, the example gujiya saves about ₹24.67 (55 - 30.33), and the example thandai about ₹33.75 (80 - 46.25). Once your time is included, the gujiya saving falls to about ₹14.67, which is still positive. For 30 gujiyas, that is roughly 30 × 14.67 = ₹440. The numbers will change with your prices, which is why you use your bills.

What do people forget to count?

  • Oil that is left over but cannot be reused for good frying, so a larger share belongs to the batch
  • Pieces that burst while frying or crack in the dough
  • Extra khoya or sugar bought for a second attempt
  • A helper or neighbour who rolled dough for you
  • Containers and foil for packing and gifting

Do you need to make a full batch?

Scale the recipe to the number of people who will eat or receive them. A big batch lowers the per-piece gas and your set-up time, but more pieces mean more that can go to waste. If you plan to gift boxes, count the box cost per gujiya too.

Is it worth making both?

Not always. In the example, thandai saves more per serving than the gujiya does once your time is counted, and thandai takes less hands-on time. If you only have an afternoon, you might make the thandai and buy the gujiya, or the other way round if your family's gujiya recipe is the one everyone waits for. Let your own bills and your own hours decide, not the tradition of doing everything from scratch.

Keeping the receipts together

Put all the shopping for the batch in one category, such as festival sweets, so the total is easy to read. SpendixAI keeps receipts with their transactions, so the khoya and sugar bills stay with the entries. You can then divide the category total by the pieces made.

Before you start cooking

  • Ingredient prices from your latest bills
  • Yield counted after frying, not before
  • Gas and oil share estimated
  • Time value chosen
  • Shop price noted for the same item
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports