Money basics

Income vs money in: why a refund or a loan credit is not earnings

Not every credit in your account is income. Sort ten sample credits, from salary to a loan, and see how it changes your savings rate.

Editorial illustration for Income vs money in: why a refund or a loan credit is not earnings

Income is money you earned or were paid for something; money in is anything that lands in your account. A refund, a borrowed amount or a friend paying you back all raise the balance, but none of them leaves you richer. If you count them as income, your savings rate looks healthier than it really is.

Ten credits, sorted

Say one month's statement shows ten credits. The table sorts them with a reason, and you can do the same with your own.

CreditAmountIncome?Why
Salary₹55,000YesPaid for your work
Refund for returned shoes₹2,400NoGives back an expense
Personal loan credited₹50,000NoBorrowed, must be repaid
Friend repays what you lent₹3,000NoYour own money returning
Savings account interest₹420YesEarned on your balance
Cashback on a bill₹150NoLowers the cost of that bill
Transfer from your other account₹10,000NoSame money, new place
Rent from a tenant₹12,000YesPaid for use of your property
Office reimbursement for travel₹3,500NoPays back what you spent
Gift from parents₹5,000Your callNot earned; label it separately

What does the sorting do to the savings rate?

Add every credit: ₹55,000 + ₹2,400 + ₹50,000 + ₹3,000 + ₹420 + ₹150 + ₹10,000 + ₹12,000 + ₹3,500 + ₹5,000 = ₹1,41,470. Now take real income only: ₹55,000 + ₹420 + ₹12,000 = ₹67,420.

Suppose spending for the month, after the shoes refund, the cashback and the office reimbursement are netted off against it, is ₹48,000.

  • Counting every credit as income: (₹1,41,470 − ₹48,000) ÷ ₹1,41,470 is about 66 percent saved. That is a flattering illusion built on a loan and a transfer.
  • Counting real income only: (₹67,420 − ₹48,000) ÷ ₹67,420 is about 29 percent saved. This is the honest figure.

Why does a refund belong against the expense?

A refund undoes part of an earlier purchase. If the shoes cost ₹2,400 in a month and came back in the same month, your shopping total should be zero, not ₹2,400 of spending plus ₹2,400 of income. When the purchase and the refund fall in different months, the earlier month keeps its spending, and the later month shows a lower net. Use the same logic for an office reimbursement: the travel was your spending, the repayment cancels it.

How should loans and repayments from friends be handled?

A loan credit is a liability appearing as cash. Keep it in a separate line, such as Borrowed, so the balance makes sense, and record each EMI that follows as an outflow. When a friend repays what you lent, that is the earlier lending coming back. If you noted the lending when it left your account, tick it off now; if you did not, label the credit Repayment received and keep it out of income.

Where can SpendixAI help?

When you import a statement, SpendixAI lists each credit as a row that you review before saving, so this is the moment to mark the non-income ones. You can also add your own categories and rules, which makes it easier to keep Refund and Borrowed apart from Salary.

What if you are unsure about a credit?

Some credits are honestly ambiguous. A cousin sends ₹5,000 towards a trip you organised: is it a repayment of what you paid on their behalf, or a gift? Decide from the facts, write a note on the entry, and apply the same choice next time. A consistent label that is slightly imperfect beats a perfect label used only in some months, because the savings rate is a trend and trends need like-for-like months.

A quick monthly routine

  • Scan the credits column first, before the debits.
  • Tag each credit as Income, Refund, Borrowed, Repayment, Transfer or Other.
  • Total only the Income tag and use that as the denominator for your savings rate.
  • Revisit any Other items at month end.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports