To decide between repairing and replacing a phone, work out the cost per year of use for each option. Divide the repair quote by the extra years it should give you, and divide the replacement price, less what your old phone fetches, by the years you expect the new one to last. Compare the two yearly figures, and add your own repair history to judge how much more the old phone will need.
What should you gather first?
- Your repair receipts so far: date, fault, cost and the shop.
- The quote for the repair you are considering, ideally in writing.
- The price of the phone you would buy, with any exchange value for the old one.
- Your honest guess of how many more years the old phone will do, and how many years a new one will last for you.
How do you compare yearly cost with example numbers?
These numbers are invented. Say the old phone has had a screen replacement of ₹6,500 and a battery change of ₹2,500, nine thousand rupees in total, and now needs a repair quoted at ₹7,000. A replacement costs ₹30,000, and the old phone would fetch ₹3,000 in exchange.
| Option | Upfront cost | Expected years | Yearly cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Repair, keep one more year | ₹7,000 | 1 | ₹7,000 |
| Repair, keep two more years | ₹7,000 | 2 | ₹3,500 |
| Replace, kept three years | ₹27,000 (30,000 - 3,000) | 3 | ₹9,000 |
Replacement costs 27,000 / 3 = ₹9,000 a year. The repair is cheaper per year as long as it buys more than 7,000 / 9,000 = 0.78 of a year, a little over nine months. Past that, repair wins on cost, and the longer the phone lasts the more it wins. If the repair shop will not say how long the fix should hold, treat the one-year row as your honest case.
What does your repair history tell you?
A phone that has needed two repairs in two years may need a third. In the example the earlier repairs cost ₹9,000. If you expect another repair of about ₹7,000 each year, the old phone costs ₹7,000 a year and the new one ₹9,000, which is close. Then other points can decide it: whether the old phone still gets software updates, how the battery lasts, and whether you need a better camera for work.
Which questions should you ask the repair shop?
- Is the part new, refurbished or from another maker?
- Is there a warranty on the repair, and for how long?
- Could the repair affect water resistance or the phone's own warranty?
- Will they put the fault and parts on the bill?
- What happens to your data, and should you back up first?
Does the decision change if the phone is for a parent or a child?
It can. A phone that is dropped often may be a bad repair candidate, since the next drop costs the same again. For a parent, ease of use and a reliable battery may matter more than the yearly figure. Write the reason next to your calculation so you remember why you chose, and look at it again when the next repair is due.
How do you keep the receipts so the comparison is easy?
SpendixAI lets you keep receipts with their transactions and give repairs a custom category, such as phone repairs. The report builder then lets you filter and group by category, so your repair history comes up in one list. Add cash payments to a repair shop by hand so they are not missing.
Closing checklist
- List past repairs with date and cost.
- Get the quote for the next one.
- Work out the yearly cost of both options.
- Note the break-even point in months.
- Decide, and save the repair bill with its warranty terms.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports

