A refund for a foreign purchase can come back as fewer rupees than you paid, or occasionally more, because the refund is usually converted at the rate on the day it is processed, not the rate on the day you bought. The merchant returns the same amount in its own currency. The rupee value of that currency has simply moved, so the two rupee figures on your statement differ. Check your own statement lines, as banks word them differently.
A worked example
Say you buy a jacket for €150 and your card statement shows ₹13,800, a rate of ₹92 per euro. Three weeks later the shop refunds €150, but the rupee value of the euro has slipped and the credit is posted at ₹89 per euro.
| Event | Euros | Rate used | Rupees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase | 150 | 92 | 13,800 |
| Refund three weeks later | 150 | 89 | 13,350 |
| Difference | 0 | 3 per euro | 450 less |
You got back ₹450 less than you paid, even though the shop returned every euro. If the euro had strengthened instead, the credit would have been higher and you would be ₹450 ahead on a different day's rates. Either way, the returned jacket cost you the difference.
Why does this happen?
Exchange rates move every day, and your bank converts foreign amounts at the rate applicable when the transaction posts. A purchase and its refund are two separate transactions on two different dates, each converted on its own day. A refund does not reverse the original conversion. It starts a new one.
Does the fee on the original purchase come back?
That depends on how your card handled it. A markup or fee that was charged as a separate line on the purchase may or may not be reversed with the refund. Check the statement lines, and if a fee line was not reversed, ask your bank how it treats refunds. Do not assume either way.
How should I record the difference?
The tidy way is to keep three rows and not tweak the original purchase:
- Purchase: ₹13,800 as an expense in shopping.
- Refund: ₹13,350 as money back, linked to the same item.
- Currency difference: ₹450, recorded as a forex loss, or as a small cost under a category such as forex fees.
The net cost of an item you returned is then ₹450, and your shopping category is not inflated by a purchase that no longer exists. If the rate moved in your favour, record the difference as a gain, or simply let the net show up as a negative cost.
Can I avoid the difference?
Not entirely, since you do not control the rate on the day of the refund. You can reduce surprises by returning things sooner, by asking whether the shop offers an exchange or credit for the same currency, and by knowing that a refund to a voucher or a different payment method behaves differently. Those choices have their own pros and cons, so decide on the item, not on a rule.
Where does a tracker help?
A tracker that stores a rate with each transaction makes this gap visible because the purchase and the refund each carry their own rate. In SpendixAI, each transaction keeps the rate saved with it, and totals in your base currency are worked out from those rates, so a foreign refund and its original purchase can be compared on their own lines.
Quick checklist
- Keep the original receipt and the refund confirmation together.
- Note the date the refund was posted, not only the date it was promised.
- Record the difference in rupees on its own row.
- If the difference looks larger than the rate move explains, ask the bank for the conversion details.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports

