Cards and UPI

Foreign currency refund came back lower: why and how to record it

Foreign currency refund came back lower than you paid? See why the rate changes between charge and refund, and how to record the difference.

Editorial illustration for Foreign currency refund came back lower: why and how to record it

A foreign-currency refund often comes back as fewer rupees because the refund is converted at the rate on the day it is processed, not the rate on the day you paid. The merchant may have returned the full foreign amount, and the rupee credit is still lower. Record the gap as a separate forex difference.

Why did the refund come back lower?

Say you paid USD 100 when the card's rate was ₹84.00. The statement charged ₹8,400. A month later the merchant refunds USD 100, but the rate on that day is ₹82.00, so the credit is ₹8,200. The merchant gave back every dollar and you are still ₹200 short.

EventForeign amountRateRupees
PurchaseUSD 100₹84.00₹8,400 debited
RefundUSD 100₹82.00₹8,200 credited
Net cost to youNil in dollarsRate change₹200

If the rate had moved the other way, the refund would have been higher than the charge. Rate movement cuts both ways, and the refund and the purchase are separate conversions.

What else can reduce a refund?

  • A fee or mark-up on the original charge, which may or may not be reversed. This depends on the issuer, so check your card's terms.
  • A partial refund, because of shipping, restocking or cancellation charges on the merchant's side.
  • A refund to a different currency or amount than you expected, because of how the merchant processed it.

How do I check which one it was?

  1. Look at the foreign amount of the refund. If it equals the foreign amount of the purchase, the merchant refunded in full.
  2. Compare the rupees. If the foreign amounts match but the rupees do not, the rate moved.
  3. Look for a separate fee line on the original charge and ask whether it was reversed.
  4. If the foreign amount of the refund is less than the purchase, ask the merchant what was deducted, and ask for it in writing.

How do I record it?

Keep your list matching the statement and also keep the cost visible. One tidy way is as follows.

  • Original purchase: ₹8,400 in its category, such as Shopping.
  • Refund: minus ₹8,400 in the same category, which cancels the purchase.
  • Forex difference: ₹200 as an expense in a category called Forex difference.

The account balance then reconciles: −₹8,400 for the refund plus ₹200 for the difference is a net credit of ₹8,200, which is what the card received. Your Shopping total shows no cost for a cancelled item, and the forex difference shows what the rate change cost you.

Keep the original receipt and the refund confirmation together. If you need to raise a query, those two documents and the statement lines are all anyone will need to see.

What if the refund is still pending?

Refunds from overseas merchants can take longer than domestic ones, and the merchant, the card network and your issuer each take some time. Record the expected refund as a note, not as a credit, until it appears on the statement, so your list matches reality. Note the date the merchant said it processed the refund, and the foreign amount, so you can ask the issuer about it with details in hand.

When should I contact the merchant or the issuer?

Ask the merchant if the foreign amount of the refund is lower than what you paid, or if it has not arrived within the time they quoted. Ask the issuer if the foreign amounts match but the rupee credit looks off against the rate for the refund day, or if a fee has not been reversed when your card's terms say it would be. Keep the receipt, the statement lines and the dates ready.

A custom Forex difference category in SpendixAI keeps these entries together, so you can see over a year what rate movement cost you on refunds.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports