Business

Repair or replace: the arithmetic for a business machine

When a machine breaks, a repair bill looks cheap beside a new purchase. Looking at age, downtime and running cost gives a fairer answer.

Editorial illustration for Repair or replace: the arithmetic for a business machine

The pull of the cheaper bill

A machine stops working. The repairer quotes 6,000. A new one costs 40,000. The repair seems an obvious choice, and often it is. But sometimes it is the first of several repairs on a failing machine, with downtime and reduced output hidden behind the individual bills.

A few numbers help decide.

Gather the facts

Collect these items before deciding.

  • Age of the machine and its expected life
  • Repair cost quoted, and what the quote covers
  • Repairs already made in the last year
  • Downtime during repairs
  • Running cost of the old machine compared with a new one
  • Price of a replacement, including installation

Not all are exact, but rough numbers are enough.

A rule of thumb

A common test compares the repair cost with the value of the machine and with the cost of the replacement. If the repair would cost more than half of a replacement, or the machine is near the end of its expected life, replacement deserves serious thought. This is only a guide, and the right answer depends on the machine and the business.

Include downtime

Downtime has a price. If the machine produces 3,000 of margin a day and a repair takes three days, the cost of waiting is 9,000, more than the repair bill itself. A replacement that arrives quickly may be cheaper in total. Conversely, a replacement with a long delivery time may be worse.

Compare yearly costs

OptionCost nowExpected extra repairs per yearExpected years of useCost per year
---------------
Repair old6,0004,00027,000
Buy new40,00050085,500

On these figures, the new machine is cheaper per year, though it requires more cash now. If cash is tight, a repair may still be the only option. The table at least shows what is being traded.

Plan ahead

Machines wear out on a schedule. A fund set aside monthly for replacement means that when the day comes, the decision rests on arithmetic, not on whether the cash exists. Keep a record of repair history for each machine, so patterns become visible.

Logging repairs by machine

In SpendixAI, record repairs under a maintenance category with the machine in the note. A year of entries shows which machines absorb most repair money. That list is a good prompt for deciding which ones to replace first.

Servicing as prevention

Many breakdowns follow skipped maintenance. A simple service calendar for each machine, with dates and costs, often prevents the failure that forces the repair-or-replace decision. Money spent on regular oiling, cleaning and inspection is usually small beside the cost of an unplanned stop.

Record every service and repair in the same place. When the pattern of repairs begins to shorten the interval between failures, the data speaks for itself, and the decision to replace is easier and less emotional.

Selling or scrapping the old machine

If replacement is chosen, do not forget the value left in the old machine. Compare offers from dealers, scrap buyers and private buyers, and record the sale proceeds when received. Any loss against the book value is a cost of the decision. Remove the machine from the equipment register and note the date. Some suppliers offer an exchange allowance on a new model, which should be weighed against selling separately.

Keeping a spare parts list

Alongside the register, list the spare parts that fail most often and the supplier for each. Holding one or two of the cheapest critical spares can cut downtime from days to hours. Record spare purchases against the machine, so the true cost of ownership includes them. A small stock of the right spares is cheaper than the production lost waiting for a courier.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports