To compare the neighbourhood kirana with a grocery app fairly, price the identical eight items on both and then add what the app charges on top: delivery, handling and any tip. In the made-up basket below, the app's item prices add up to ₹6 less than the shop, but its extra charges turn that into a ₹56 higher final bill.
What does the side-by-side table look like?
List item, pack size, shop price and app price on one row, then the fees below. All figures are invented for the example.
| Item | Pack | Kirana | App |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atta | 5 kg | ₹260 | ₹255 |
| Toor dal | 1 kg | ₹165 | ₹170 |
| Sunflower oil | 1 L | ₹150 | ₹148 |
| Tea | 250 g | ₹135 | ₹130 |
| Sugar | 1 kg | ₹48 | ₹47 |
| Rice | 5 kg | ₹390 | ₹395 |
| Detergent powder | 1 kg | ₹120 | ₹115 |
| Biscuits | 3 packs | ₹60 | ₹62 |
| Items subtotal | All eight | ₹1,328 | ₹1,322 |
Adding the kirana column gives 260 plus 165 plus 150 plus 135 plus 48 plus 390 plus 120 plus 60, which is ₹1,328. The app column adds up to ₹1,322 (255 plus 170 plus 148 plus 130 plus 47 plus 395 plus 115 plus 62).
Which extra rows decide the answer?
| Row | Kirana | App |
|---|---|---|
| Items subtotal | ₹1,328 | ₹1,322 |
| Delivery fee | ₹0 | ₹35 |
| Handling or small-order fee | ₹0 | ₹7 |
| Tip to the delivery person | ₹0 | ₹20 |
| Final total | ₹1,328 | ₹1,384 |
The app's extras are ₹62 (35 plus 7 plus 20), so its final total is ₹1,384, and the kirana is cheaper by ₹56. If the app had waived its fees because the basket crossed a free-delivery limit, the result would flip by ₹6 in favour of the app. A small change in fees or a larger basket moves the winner, which is why the rows matter more than the headline price.
What about the things that are not in the table?
- Travel to the kirana: if you walk, it is zero; if you ride, add fuel as you would for any trip.
- Discounts on the app that depend on the day or your first order. Count a discount only if it will recur.
- Pack sizes and brands: a 1 kg pack online may be a different brand from the one on the shop shelf.
- Quality and freshness: check expiry dates on both sides for the same basket.
- Credit: a kirana that lets you pay at month end gives you something an app does not.
How do I repeat the check without redoing everything?
Keep the eight items in a sheet with a column for each side and put the fee rows at the bottom. Next time only the prices change. Add a row for the final total with =SUM(B2:B9) for items and the fees below it. Doing the comparison once every couple of months is enough.
Your statements can supply the real fees. If you import app orders from a card or bank statement into SpendixAI, you can see what you paid in total for each app order, and compare it with what the shop would have charged for the same basket.
A related check is the missing-item test. Count how many of the eight items the app delivered in the right brand and size, and how many were substituted. A substituted item you did not want is a cost even if the price is lower, and an item that is out of stock at the shop means a second trip. Note both in a remarks column.
Reading the result without picking a side
- If the totals differ by a few rupees, choose on convenience and trust.
- If one side wins by a large amount most weeks, shift the regular items there.
- Use the other side for what it does best, such as emergencies or heavy items.
- Re-run the comparison when fees, offers or your basket change.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports


