Home and property

Solar water heater against an electric geyser: a cost-log comparison

Compare a solar water heater with an electric geyser using your own bills: purchase, service and electricity lines before and after, with prices you supply.

Editorial illustration for Solar water heater against an electric geyser: a cost-log comparison

To compare a solar water heater with an electric geyser, use your own records: what you paid to buy and install, what you spend on service each year, and how many electricity units and rupees you spent before and after. The prices below are made up; replace them with your own quotes and bills.

What does the electric geyser cost to run?

Find the power rating on the geyser's plate, in watts or kilowatts, and estimate hours of use per day. Units per month equal kilowatts times hours times days. Say a 2 kW geyser runs 1 hour a day for 30 days. That is 2 times 1 times 30, or 60 units. At an assumed ₹6 per unit, that is ₹360 a month. The real figure depends on how long it actually heats, which varies with the season, the thermostat and the tank size.

What goes in the solar water heater column?

  • Purchase and installation, from the invoice
  • Any subsidy or incentive received, noted separately and only if you actually received it
  • Annual service or cleaning, with date and amount
  • Repairs: valves, tank, sensors
  • Electric backup use: many systems have a backup heating element, and your bill will show whether it is used

How do you compare before and after?

Use the same months for both. Take the units from the three months before the installation and the same three months a year later, because season changes the answer. Then compute the difference and its value in rupees. Say the average monthly units were 260 before and 200 after. That is a drop of 60 units, worth 60 times ₹6, which is ₹360 a month, or ₹4,320 a year.

LineElectric geyser onlyWith solar water heater
Purchase and installation (₹)Already owned28,000
Yearly service (₹)01,000
Average monthly units260200
Monthly electricity cost at ₹6 per unit (₹)1,5601,200
Yearly electricity cost (₹)18,72014,400

260 units at ₹6 is ₹1,560, and 200 units at ₹6 is ₹1,200. All values here are hypothetical. The yearly electricity saving is 18,720 minus 14,400, which is ₹4,320. After yearly service of ₹1,000, the net saving is ₹3,320. Dividing the purchase cost of 28,000 by 3,320 gives about 8.4 years to recover the money. A different tariff, a bigger household or a higher price would change the answer.

What else belongs in the comparison?

  1. Resale or scrap value of the old geyser
  2. Weather: cloudy or rainy months where the backup element is used more
  3. Space, roof access and shading
  4. Water quality and maintenance, such as scale in the tubes
  5. How long you expect to live in the house

How do you log it in a sheet?

Make one table of monthly units and amount for the twelve months before, and another for twelve months after. Use =AVERAGE() on each, subtract to get the unit difference, and multiply by the rate on your bill. For payback use =Purchase/(YearlySaving-YearlyService). Replace the figures with your own, and revisit after a full year.

Where do the payments sit?

The purchase, the annual service and the electricity bills can each go in their own categories, so a report can show the totals by year. SpendixAI can total these from imported statements and keep the invoice with the purchase, while the unit counts stay in your sheet. Whether any subsidy or tax benefit applies is a question for the seller or a chartered accountant, and rules change.

Decision checklist

  • Your own quotes for both options, with dates
  • Twelve months of electricity bills before, and after if you already switched
  • One-time and yearly costs separated
  • A note for anything else that changed in the household
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports