Money basics

Sum insured against real bills: a what-if example

Choosing a sum insured is easier when you test it against plausible bills. A small what-if table makes the question concrete.

Editorial illustration for Sum insured against real bills: a what-if example

A number that needs a reality check

The sum insured is often chosen by habit, by what a friend has or by what fits a premium. A better method is to test it against bills that could plausibly occur. This does not predict the future or recommend an amount. It simply lets you see how different scenarios would play out with the cover you hold, so that you can decide with your eyes open.

Hospital costs differ with place, hospital and condition, so use your own records, quotes and the guidance of professionals, not general claims.

Build the scenarios

Choose three or four situations: a short stay for a minor procedure, a longer stay for a more serious one, an emergency admission with intensive care and a prolonged treatment over months. Estimate a cost for each from your own records, hospital estimates or the doctor’s guidance, and mark them as rough.

Run them against the policy

For each scenario, apply the policy terms you know: sum insured, co-payment, deductible, room limit and sub-limits. Work out how much the insurer would pay and how much you would. Use the same method as in the worked examples of those terms.

ScenarioEstimated billInsurer paysYou pay
Short minor stay60,00054,0006,000
Longer serious stay300,000250,00050,000
Intensive care admission700,000500,000 (cap reached)200,000
Long treatment over months900,000500,000 (cap reached)400,000

In this made-up case, the sum insured of 500,000 is sufficient for the first two scenarios but leaves a large share for the last two. That does not tell you what to do, but it tells you where the exposure is.

Ask what could fill the gap

For the scenarios where your share is high, consider the options: a higher sum insured, a top-up arrangement, a larger medical reserve, or accepting the risk consciously. Each has a cost. Compare the cost with the protection it provides. A licensed adviser can help interpret the choices for your situation.

Revisit with changes in life

Medical costs, family size, age and income all change. Re-run the table when something significant happens and at least every couple of years. Keep the older versions to see how your thinking evolved.

Keep the reserve in view

Whatever you decide on cover, the household’s share must still be paid from somewhere. The what-if table gives a target for the medical reserve. If the 50,000 in the second scenario is the realistic share, then having that amount accessible is the most direct protection.

Seen this way, the sum insured is one part of a plan, not the whole of it.

Adding a line for your own share

For each scenario in the table, add the extra costs that insurance never pays: travel, food, loss of income, home help. The sum of the household’s share and these extras gives the real burden. A scenario that looks well covered by the insurer can still be heavy for the family once the extras are counted.

This broader table is the better one for setting the medical reserve, because the reserve has to deal with whatever the policy does not.

Using scenarios to compare policies

The same table can compare two policies. Fill the insurer pays column for each, using their terms, and see where they differ. A policy with a lower premium may leave a larger share in some scenarios, which you can set against the annual saving. The comparison is more informative than a list of features, because it shows the effect in money.

Keep the table with your insurance notes and update it at renewal. It gives your decisions a history and a reason.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports