Business

This month's profit is lower than last month's: a 20-minute check

Why is profit lower than last month? A 20-minute bridge through sales, margin, costs and one-offs, with a worked example of a ₹14,000 fall.

Editorial illustration for This month's profit is lower than last month's: a 20-minute check

When profit falls, the reason is almost always one of four things: you sold less, you earned less on each sale, your regular costs rose, or something one-off hit the month. A 20-minute bridge from last month's profit to this month's will tell you which, and it uses only figures you already have.

What do I need on the table before I start?

  • Last month's and this month's total sales.
  • The gross margin for each month, meaning (sales minus the cost of goods sold) divided by sales.
  • Each fixed cost line for both months: rent, salaries, electricity, EMIs and so on.
  • Any unusual bill you remember, such as a repair, a festival bonus or a fine.

Put both months side by side, one column each. Do not look for the answer by feel; the arithmetic is quick and it stops you blaming the wrong cause.

A made-up fall of ₹14,000, explained

Say last month you sold ₹3,00,000 at a 25 percent margin, so gross profit was ₹75,000. Fixed costs were ₹23,000, leaving a profit of ₹52,000. This month you sold ₹2,90,000 at 23 percent, so gross profit was ₹66,700. Fixed costs came to ₹28,700, leaving ₹38,000. The profit fell by ₹14,000. Where did it go?

CauseWorkingEffect on profit
Fewer sales₹10,000 less sold, at last month's 25 percent marginMinus ₹2,500
Lower margin₹2,90,000 sold, margin 2 points lower (23 against 25)Minus ₹5,800
Regular costs roseElectricity went up by ₹1,700Minus ₹1,700
One-off costA freezer repair of ₹4,000Minus ₹4,000
Total₹2,500 + ₹5,800 + ₹1,700 + ₹4,000Minus ₹14,000

The surprise here is that falling sales explain only a small part. The margin slip is the biggest piece, so the useful question is not "why are customers buying less" but "why did we earn two points less on what we sold".

What makes the margin slip?

  • A supplier raised prices and your shelf prices stayed the same.
  • More discounts, offers or free items than usual.
  • Wastage or expiry on items bought in bulk.
  • A change in what sells: more of the low-margin staples, less of the higher-margin items.
  • Mistakes in billing, such as an old price still in the system.

Is a one-off cost really a one-off?

Be honest with the repair or the bonus. If a freezer repair happens every few months, it belongs in regular costs, and the real trend is worse than the bridge suggests. Mark each item as one-off, recurring or unsure, and look at the same line again next month before deciding.

What if the bridge does not add up?

When the four effects do not match the fall, the usual culprit is the cost of goods sold. It is opening stock plus purchases minus closing stock, not just what you bought. Say you bought ₹2,60,000 of goods but stock on the shelf rose by ₹20,000. The goods actually sold cost ₹2,40,000, and using ₹2,60,000 would make the margin look about six points worse than it is. If you do not count stock, at least note any month with an unusually large purchase before judging the margin.

What do I do with the answer?

Pick the biggest cause and act on that alone: reprice a few items, renegotiate a supplier, stop a leak. If your shop expenses go through a bank account, SpendixAI's category reports can show which spending lines grew from month to month, which saves hunting through the statement for the cost rows.

  1. Write both months' sales, margin and fixed costs in two columns.
  2. Work out the volume, margin and cost effects as in the table.
  3. Tag each cost as one-off, recurring or unsure.
  4. Choose one action for the biggest cause and set a date to recheck.
SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports