Getting started

Track investments without counting them as spending

Money you put into investments is not an expense. Here is how to record SIPs and deposits separately so your monthly spending number stays honest.

Editorial illustration for Track investments without counting them as spending

The mistake most people make when they track investments alongside spending is counting a SIP or a deposit as an expense. It is money moved, not money spent, so it needs its own bucket. Keep it out of your spending total and your monthly picture becomes much clearer.

Spending, saving and investing are three different lines

  • Spending: money gone for good, such as rent, food, travel and bills.
  • Saving: money set aside, such as a recurring deposit or a goal fund.
  • Investing: money you put into assets whose value moves, such as units bought through a SIP.

If all three sit in one list called expenses, a month where you invested more looks like a month where you overspent. Separating them stops that.

A worked month

Say your monthly income is ₹70,000. All figures are made up.

LineAmount (₹)
Income70,000
Rent18,000
Food and groceries9,000
Everything else spent15,000
Total spending42,000
SIP contributions8,000
Recurring deposit5,000
Total set aside13,000
Left unallocated15,000

The sums: 18,000 + 9,000 + 15,000 = 42,000 spent; 8,000 + 5,000 = 13,000 set aside; 70,000 − 42,000 − 13,000 = 15,000 left. If you had counted the 13,000 as spending, your spending would read 55,000, which is wrong by almost a third.

How do you record it?

  1. Make a separate category or account group for each destination: SIP, deposit, goal fund.
  2. When an auto-debit for a SIP appears on your statement, file it there rather than in general expenses.
  3. Review rows after any statement import, because a SIP debit can look like an ordinary merchant payment.
  4. Keep a short list of what each recurring amount is for, with the date it runs.

What an expense tracker does not do

An expense tracker records what left your account. It will not value your holdings or show returns, and SpendixAI does not track investments. For current value you need the statements from the platforms where the money sits, and for decisions about what to invest in you need an adviser you trust. Nothing here is a recommendation.

Ask the monthly question

Once spending and investing are separate you can ask a useful question: of everything that came in, how much was spent, how much was set aside, and how much is simply sitting in the bank? In the example, 15,000 sits unallocated. That is a prompt to decide on purpose, rather than to drift.

Handling lump sums and withdrawals

Not every investment is a monthly SIP. A one-off lump sum, a top-up or a withdrawal should each be recorded as a movement with its own date and amount. A withdrawal that comes back into your bank is a transfer in, not income, and should not make a month look richer than it was. When you are unsure how to treat an item, note it in a comment and ask your adviser or CA; the date and amount are what matter most.

Keep one short note listing every recurring debit with its purpose and day of the month. If a debit stops or changes, you will notice the gap straight away, and the list is useful when you review your plans at the start of the financial year.

A tidy-up for the end of the month

  • Total spending, set aside and unallocated, in that order.
  • Compare the SIP and deposit total with what you intended to commit.
  • Note any missed or extra debit and the reason.
  • Download a CSV of the month if you want to keep a record outside the app.

SpendixAI keeps custom categories, so you can set up an Investments or Transfers group and keep it separate from spending in reports.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports