Shopping

TV on EMI or save first? A worked comparison with sample numbers

One made-up ₹40,000 TV compared two ways, month by month: instalments with a fee against seven months of saving, including what you watch on the old set.

Editorial illustration for TV on EMI or save first? A worked comparison with sample numbers

Whether to buy a TV on EMI or save first comes down to a month-by-month comparison of what leaves your account under each plan. Take one made-up ₹40,000 TV, run eight instalments with a fee against seven months of saving, add the cost of making the old TV last, and see the gap in rupees. Then decide with your own numbers.

What are the two plans?

Plan A: you take the TV home now and pay eight monthly instalments of ₹5,300, plus a one-time processing fee of ₹400 in the first month. These figures are invented, not any lender's schedule. Plan B: you save ₹5,715 a month for seven months (about ₹40,000 / 7, rounded up) and buy the TV for cash at the end of month seven.

MonthPlan A paid so farPlan B saved so farTV at home?
1₹5,700₹5,715A: yes. B: no
2₹11,000₹11,430A: yes. B: no
3₹16,300₹17,145A: yes. B: no
4₹21,600₹22,860A: yes. B: no
5₹26,900₹28,575A: yes. B: no
6₹32,200₹34,290A: yes. B: no
7₹37,500₹40,005A: yes. B: buys now
8₹42,800₹40,005Both yes

What is the extra cost of the instalment plan?

Plan A pays ₹5,700 in month one (₹5,300 + ₹400) and ₹5,300 for seven more months, so the total is ₹5,700 + 7 x ₹5,300 = ₹42,800. Plan B pays ₹40,005. The difference is ₹42,800 - ₹40,005 = ₹2,795, which is the price of having the TV seven months earlier in this example.

What does waiting cost you?

The saving plan is not free either. For seven months you watch on the old TV, and it may need attention. Say the old set needs a ₹1,200 repair to last that long. Then Plan B's true cost is ₹40,005 + ₹1,200 = ₹41,205, and the gap between the plans shrinks to ₹42,800 - ₹41,205 = ₹1,595. If the household goes to a neighbour's house or pays for something else to watch a big match, add that too.

What else should the comparison include?

  • Whether the TV's price may change during the wait. It may move either way, so check a few weeks apart and note the dates.
  • A festival sale that may fall inside your saving window, and the price at that time.
  • The risk that the saved money gets used for something urgent, which is why some people put it in a separate account.
  • The risk, under Plan A, that your income dips while instalments continue.
  • Any charge for paying the instalments off early, as the lender's terms state.

How do you decide with your own numbers?

  1. Write the TV's cash price and the lender's total payable from the schedule.
  2. Subtract the cash price from the total payable to get the cost of the instalment plan.
  3. Estimate the cost of waiting, such as a repair or alternative viewing.
  4. Divide the cash price by the months you could realistically save.
  5. Compare the monthly outflow from each plan with your take-home and fixed costs.

The plan with the lower total is not automatically the right one. If ₹5,715 a month is a stretch, the smaller instalment may be the safer path, and if you have the cash sitting idle, the cheaper total may win. A fair comparison only gives you the numbers to weigh.

How can a tracker help you stick to the plan?

If you choose to save, SpendixAI Pro includes savings goals that can hold the target. If you choose instalments, the debits arrive on your imported statement and you can check them against the schedule. Either way, the sheet above stays your reference.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports