Money basics

Comparing your household against itself, not the neighbours

Other households’ spending is a poor yardstick. Your own history, adjusted for life changes, is a far fairer and more useful comparison.

Editorial illustration for Comparing your household against itself, not the neighbours

The trouble with outside comparisons

It is tempting to wonder whether the household spends too much on food, transport or children. A neighbour, a colleague or an online figure gets quoted, and the household measures itself against it. But other households differ in size, income, location, health, priorities and stage of life. A comparison that ignores these differences usually misleads.

Worse, it breeds either complacency or anxiety. A household that spends less than a friend may relax unnecessarily. One that spends more may feel guilty about choices that are perfectly sensible for its situation.

A better benchmark: your own past

Your own records provide a benchmark that already accounts for your circumstances. Compare this quarter with the same quarter last year, or this month with the average of the last six. The question becomes: what has changed, and why?

This comparison shows real movement in the household’s life. A 12 percent rise in utilities is information about your home, not about anyone else’s.

Adjust for life changes

Raw comparisons need a few adjustments. Ask whether the household changed in a way that explains the numbers.

  • **Size:** a new member, or someone moving out.
  • **Location:** a change of home or area.
  • **Work:** a different commute, hybrid arrangements, a new job.
  • **Health:** an illness, a regular treatment.
  • **Season:** festival months, weather, school calendar.

If the change is explained, the number may be reasonable. If not, it deserves a closer look.

A comparison table

CategoryLast year, monthly averageThis year, monthly averageExplained by
Food and supplies17,60019,400Extra household member
Transport5,2004,100Remote work two days a week
Utilities6,0007,300Longer cooling season
Leisure3,5003,600Unchanged

The table helps separate the changes with a clear cause from those without. If utilities rose beyond the explanation, an investigation is in order.

Per-person and per-unit measures

Where household size changes, divide by the number of people to compare. A food bill of 19,400 for four is 4,850 per person, against 17,600 for three, which is 5,867 per person. Per-person spending actually fell. Similarly, consider cost per kilometre or per unit of utility where the data exist.

Look at shares, not just amounts

The proportion of income going to each category can reveal shifts even when absolute amounts rise with income. If housing took 32 percent of income last year and 36 percent this year, something moved.

Shares are especially helpful when income changes. A raise that is entirely absorbed by rising commitments leaves the household no better off.

Using outside figures sensibly

There is nothing wrong with curiosity about others. Treat outside figures as prompts for questions, not as targets. If someone mentions a cheaper provider, check the terms. If a household of similar size spends far less on a category, ask what they do differently. Then decide whether the practice would suit you.

Setting your own targets

Based on your history, set modest goals: reduce a category by a few percent, increase savings by a small step. Make progress measured against yourselves. A household that improves steadily on its own record is doing well, whatever others do.

A yearly exercise

At the annual review, include a section on year-over-year comparison. Note what changed in the household’s life, which numbers moved, and which were surprising. Over the years, this record becomes a map of the household’s financial story.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports