Money basics

Digital downloads you cannot resell: the real cost of ownership

Digital purchases cannot be lent, resold or always kept forever. Weighing that against the lower price and convenience gives a fairer picture of what a download really costs.

Editorial illustration for Digital downloads you cannot resell: the real cost of ownership

Buying a licence, not an object

When you buy a physical book, you own the copy. You can lend it, give it away or sell it second-hand. When you buy a digital book, film, game or track, you usually buy a licence to use it under terms set by the seller. The licence may be tied to an account, a platform or a device.

This is not a complaint. It is a feature of the product that should enter your price comparison.

What resale value means

A physical game bought at 3,000 units might sell second-hand for 1,500, so its net cost to you is 1,500 plus the time of selling. A digital copy at 2,700 is cheaper at the checkout but has no resale value, so its net cost stays 2,700.

Compare net cost over the time you will own the item, not just the shelf price. If you finish a game quickly and never replay it, resale value matters. If you keep and reuse it for years, it matters less.

Convenience has value too

Digital purchases arrive instantly, take no shelf space and often cost less. For items you will use once, such as a how-to guide, that convenience is worth paying for. For items you will keep and want to access a decade from now, think carefully about the platform’s stability.

Questions before you click

  1. Will I want to lend or resell this?
  2. Can I download it in a form I control?
  3. What happens if the platform changes its terms or closes?
  4. Is there a physical or open alternative at a comparable price?
  5. How often will I use it?

Not every question matters for every item. Use them as prompts.

Storage and access

Digital libraries can be hard to browse over time. Keep a simple list of what you own and where, perhaps in a note, with the platform and date of purchase. In Spendix, give each purchase a clear name and category so you can search later when you wonder whether you already own something.

Consider sharing arrangements

Some platforms allow sharing within a family under specific rules. Read the current terms. Where sharing is allowed, the cost per person can fall, making the digital copy better value than a physical one.

Review your library

Once a year, look through your purchases and ask what you actually used. The answer may change how you buy next year, preferring rentals, libraries or subscriptions for items you consume once.

A worked comparison across three years

Suppose a physical copy costs 3,000, sells second-hand for 1,500 after a year, and a digital copy costs 2,700 with no resale value. If you keep the item for only a year, the physical copy costs you 1,500 net and the digital one 2,700. If you keep it for five years, both cost their purchase price in effect, and the digital one is cheaper by 300 plus the shelf space.

The comparison changes with the time you keep and use the item. A product you will finish and forget favours the physical copy or a rental. A product you will return to often favours whichever is cheaper at purchase. Think about your own behaviour with similar items in the past.

Planning for platform changes

Digital items depend on the platform that sells them. If you have invested heavily in one library, consider the effect of a change in terms or a closure. Where possible, keep local copies in open formats, and note in Spendix which platform holds which purchase. This is a small act of caution, not a reason to avoid digital purchases altogether.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports