Saving money

Money held for someone else is not your savings

Advances, deposits and shared pots can swell a balance without belonging to you. Separating them keeps both your savings figure and your obligations honest.

Editorial illustration for Money held for someone else is not your savings

A balance that is not entirely yours

Your account shows 70,000. Within it sits 15,000 received as an advance for a service not yet delivered, 8,000 collected from friends for a shared booking, and a refundable deposit that must go back in a month. Your real savings are far lower than the number on the screen.

It helps to say the split out loud in plain numbers. Of 70,000, perhaps 47,000 is yours to plan with, and the remaining 23,000 is simply passing through on its way to someone else.

This is easy to overlook. The bank does not mark such money as borrowed, and a tracker records it as income or a deposit unless told otherwise.

Kinds of money held for others

Several situations create this pattern.

  • An advance paid to you before work is done.
  • Money collected from others to pay a group cost.
  • A refundable deposit received from a tenant, a customer or a guest.
  • A payment received on behalf of a relative.
  • A reimbursement that will pass straight on to someone else.

In each case, you are holding the money temporarily, and the obligation to hand it over remains.

Why it distorts the picture

If these amounts are counted as savings, your savings rate and your reserve appear stronger than they are. You may then feel free to spend, only to find that the money must be returned. At the other end, counting a group payment as income inflates your earnings for the month, and the later payment out appears as an expense that was never really yours.

Recording them cleanly

The simplest approach is to keep a separate account or pot for held money. Move the amount there on arrival and record it as a transfer, not income.

EventHow to record
Advance received for later workHeld money, not income until earned
Group contributions collectedHeld money, paid out as a transfer
Refundable deposit receivedHeld money, returned later
Deposit you paid and expect backRefundable asset, not spending

If your app has no dedicated feature, a goal named “Held for others” does the job. The name states the truth.

Recognising income at the right time

An advance becomes income when the work is done, not when the money arrives. Until then, the held balance is an obligation. When the work is complete, move the amount from held money to your income, and record it as earned on that date. Rules on timing can differ for tax and business purposes, so check with a qualified professional if this applies to you.

Keeping the money safe

Avoid using held money for your own spending, even temporarily. It is easy to borrow from it and then struggle to return it. If you must, record it as a loan from the held pot and repay promptly. Treat returning other people’s money as a priority.

Be especially careful when the held money sits in the same account as your reserve. A single careless payment can leave you short just when the other party asks for their share.

Communicating and documenting

Keep a message, receipt or note for each item held: who gave it, how much, why and when it is due back. Share a short statement with the other party if requested. Clear records prevent disputes and protect relationships.

For informal arrangements among friends or family, a short message confirming the amount and purpose is enough. It need not feel formal, and it protects the friendship as much as the money.

Counting your true savings

When you compute savings, subtract held money from the account balances. A quick formula: total in accounts, minus money held for others, minus money already promised to bills, gives your free position. Use that figure when you decide what you can afford.

A tidy month-end check

Add a line to your monthly review: list items held, with amounts and due dates. Confirm that the held pot matches the list. Anything that has been returned should be removed, and anything overdue should be actioned.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports